Sectoral Investment in Input-Output Frameworks, a Reply
Open Access
- 1 February 2026
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Walter de Gruyter GmbH in Peace Economics, Peace Science and Public Policy
- Vol. 32 (1) , 101-112
Abstract
This note responds to the comments by Garbellini (2026) on the treatment of demand shocks in the Input-Output model in Stamegna et al. (2024). We show that the increase in arms expenditure is correctly identified as an investment shock, while increases in public expenditure on environmental protection, education, and health services should be more appropriately interpreted as public consumption shocks. Once import shares consistent with this interpretation are applied, the central result of Stamegna et al. (2024) – namely, the higher employment effects of civilian expenditure relative to arms procurement – is further reinforced, with only minor changes in estimates. Furthermore, in Stamegna et al. (2024) the shares of arms imports are estimated using data for European countries and, even under a zero-import-share assumption, the main results are shown to be robust. Finally, we show that reducing the dimensionality of the Input-Output table yields results that are almost identical to those that we obtain here using the disaggregated tables.Keywords
This publication has 9 references indexed in Scilit:
- Sectoral Investment in Input-Output Frameworks: A Note on Stamegna et al. (2024)Peace Economics, Peace Science and Public Policy, 2026
- The Economic Impact of Arms Spending in Germany, Italy, and SpainPeace Economics, Peace Science and Public Policy, 2024
- The Fourth Industrial Revolution and Military-Civil Fusion2023
- The evolution of concentration in the arms marketThe Economics of Peace and Security Journal, 2016
- The U.S. Employment Effects of Military and Domestic Spending PrioritiesInternational Journal of Health Services, 2009
- Defense Industry Restructuring: Trends in European and U.S. Defense CompaniesTransition Studies Review, 2006
- Sectoral effects of reductions in NATO military expenditures in the major industrialized and developing countriesOpen Economies Review, 1993
- Military Spending. Facts and Figures Worldwide Implicatione and Future outlook1989
- The Economic Effects of DisarmamentScientific American, 1961