Analysing national practices after European state aid control: are multi-stakeholder negotiations beneficial for public service broadcasting?
- 1 March 2012
- journal article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Media, Culture & Society
- Vol. 34 (2) , 162-180
Abstract
This article analyses the increasing emphasis on multi-stakeholder approaches in the development of public broadcasting policies. The European Commission, in particular, reinforces this trend, having pointed to the necessity of ‘third parties’ being involved in procedures that allow public broadcasters to expand activities to new media markets. The article’s research question is twofold. First, what type of multi-stakeholder approach has been advocated for by the Commission? Second, are multi-stakeholder approaches, implemented by Member States after an encounter with the Commission, adding to more democratic (understood as more inclusive) decision-making on public service broadcasting or, rather, simply providing an additional forum for private sector interests? Evidence derives from two case studies in the Netherlands and Flanders, where some form of ex ante evaluation has been developed and a multi-stakeholder consultation has been set up in preparation for management contract renewals. Findings show that the newly developed multi-stakeholder policy practices are far from inclusive and fail to meet several aspects of deliberative democracy. Essentially, they have been created in response to market pressures (and, hence, over-focus on market questions) and rarely take as their starting point the improvement of public service broadcasting as a democratic policy project.Keywords
This publication has 14 references indexed in Scilit:
- The Netherlands2012
- Actors and Interactions in Global Communication Governance: The Heuristic Potential of a Network Approach2011
- Public Service Broadcasting: Product (and Victim?) of Public Policy2011
- Towards PSB 2.0? Applying the PSB ethos to online media in Europe: A comparative study of PSBs’ internet policies in Spain, Italy and BritainEuropean Journal of Communication, 2010
- The benefits of introducing European competition principles into national public broadcasting policyinfo, 2010
- The introduction of an ex ante evaluation for new media services: Is Europe asking for it, or does public service broadcasting need it?International Journal of Media & Cultural Politics, 2010
- Does EU Policy Challenge the Digital Future of Public Service Broadcasting?Convergence: The International Journal of Research into New Media Technologies, 2008
- Can PSB Stake its Claim in a Media World of Digital Convergence?Convergence: The International Journal of Research into New Media Technologies, 2008
- Public service broadcasting in the digital world2007
- Digital public broadcasting in Flanders: walking the tightropeTelematics and Informatics, 2003