Avoiding Climate Change: “Agnostic Adaptation” and the Politics of Public Silence
Author:
- 20 December 2018
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Annals of the American Association of Geographers
- Vol. 109 (2) , 568-580
Abstract
What does it mean to adapt to climate change without talking about climate change? The term agnostic adaptation has emerged to refer to actions that address climate change’s effects without acknowledging its existence or human causes. Although prevalent, agnostic adaptation has yet to be the focus of significant empirical research. Most studies of climate silence and denial examine the absence of action rather than its paradoxical presence. This article, by contrast, explores how action and silence coexist and even serve to reinforce each other. It draws on fieldwork in Staten Island, New York City’s most politically conservative and only predominantly white borough, where residents mobilized after Hurricane Sandy in favor of government buyouts of their damaged homes that would pay them to relocate rather than rebuild in place. The areas that received buyouts have been lauded from afar as exemplary sites of community-led climate adaptation in one of its most radical forms, managed retreat. On the ground, however, those who participated in the push for retreat were largely silent on the topic of climate change, which was not seen as politically enabling or efficacious to discuss. Agnostic adaptation minimized conflict, made for more tractable claims, and maintained relations of power but in so doing offered protection to only a select few. These findings point to the practical effects of climate silence as it exists in relation to climate talk, both of which share omissions, erasures, and forms of agnosticism that narrow the space for transformative action. Key Words: adaptation, climate change, denial, disaster, environmental politics.Keywords
Funding Information
- Mellon/ACLS Dissertation Completion Fellowship
- Mellon Postdoctoral Fellowship in the Humanities at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology
This publication has 18 references indexed in Scilit:
- Social Movement Theory and the Prospects for Climate Change Activism in the United StatesAnnual Review of Political Science, 2017
- Reframing adaptation: The political nature of climate change adaptationGlobal Environmental Change, 2015
- Walk the Walk but Don't Talk the Talk: The Strategic Use of Color‐Blind Ideology in an Interracial Social Movement OrganizationSociological Forum, 2015
- Knowing Climate Change, Embodying Climate Praxis: Experiential Knowledge in Southern AppalachiaAnnals of the American Association of Geographers, 2015
- Sea level rise, storm risk, denial, and the future of coastal citiesBulletin of the Atomic Scientists, 2015
- Disavowing Politics: Civic Engagement in an Era of Political SkepticismAmerican Journal of Sociology, 2013
- The climate gapClimate and Development, 2012
- Apocalypse Forever?Theory, Culture & Society, 2010
- Marginalization, Facilitation, and the Production of Unequal Risk: The 2006 Paso del Norte FloodsAntipode, 2010
- "People Want to Protect Themselves a Little Bit": Emotions, Denial, and Social Movement Nonparticipation*Sociological Inquiry, 2006