Evaluating community deliberations about health research priorities
Open Access
- 28 June 2019
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wiley in Health Expectations
- Vol. 22 (4) , 772-784
Abstract
Context: Engaging underrepresented communities in health research priority setting could make the scientific agenda more equitable and more responsive to their needs.Objective: Evaluate democratic deliberations engaging minority and underserved communities in setting health research priorities.Methods: Participants from underrepresented communities throughout Michigan (47 groups, n = 519) engaged in structured deliberations about health research priorities in professionally facilitated groups. We evaluated some aspects of the structure, process, and outcomes of deliberations, including representation, equality of participation, participants’ views of deliberations, and the impact of group deliberations on individual participants’ knowledge, attitudes, and points of view. Follow‐up interviews elicited richer descriptions of these and also explored later effects on deliberators.Results: Deliberators (age 18‐88 years) overrepresented minority groups. Participation in discussions was well distributed. Deliberators improved their knowledge about disparities, but not about health research. Participants, on average, supported using their group's decision to inform decision makers and would trust a process like this to inform funding decisions. Views of deliberations were the strongest predictor of these outcomes. Follow‐up interviews revealed deliberators were particularly struck by their experience hearing and understanding other points of view, sometimes surprised at the group's ability to reach agreement, and occasionally activated to volunteer or advocate.Conclusions: Deliberations using a structured group exercise to engage minority and underserved community members in setting health research priorities met some important criteria for a fair, credible process that could inform policy. Deliberations appeared to change some opinions, improved some knowledge, and were judged by participants worth using to inform policymakers.Keywords
Funding Information
- National Institute on Aging (1RO1AG040138-01)
This publication has 33 references indexed in Scilit:
- A Framework for Assessing the Quality of Democratic Deliberation: Enhancing Deliberation as a Tool for BioethicsJournal of Empirical Research on Human Research Ethics, 2011
- Experience in the United States With Public Deliberation About Health Insurance Benefits Using the Small Group Decision Exercise, CHATJournal of Ambulatory Care Management, 2010
- Family Disputes: Diversity in Defining and Measuring DeliberationSwiss Political Science Review, 2007
- Health insurance benefit packages prioritized by low-income clients in India: Three criteria to estimate effectiveness of choiceSocial Science & Medicine, 2007
- (De)constructing ‘Basic’ Benefits: Citizens Define The Limits Of CoverageHealth Affairs, 2006
- The Coverage Priorities of Disabled Adult Medi-Cal BeneficiariesJournal Of Health Care For The Poor and Underserved, 2006
- Dollars, disease, and democracyPolitics and the Life Sciences, 2005
- A Conceptual Definition and Theoretical Model of Public Deliberation in Small Face?to?Face GroupsCommunication Theory, 2002
- Whatever happened to qualitative description?Research in Nursing & Health, 2000
- Allocating Health Care: Cost-Utility Analysis, Informed Democratic Decision Making, or the Veil of Ignorance?Journal of Health Politics, Policy and Law, 1996