Violence and Epistemology
Open Access
- 7 January 2016
- journal article
- research article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Political Research Quarterly
- Vol. 69 (1) , 96-107
Abstract
Although some of his most important writings date to the period immediately after the Indian Revolt of 1857, J. S. Mill seemed unable to recognize that British violence might substantively contradict British people’s “civilized” character. Likewise, he could not view Indian actions, including recent insurgent violence, as political but rather only as expressions of “barbarian” character, nor could he consider the occasional reforming native leader effective in producing lasting political change. What enabled Mill to ignore evidence that contradicted his firm generalizations about essentially “barbarian” Indians and “civilized” Britons? Arguing that Mill wrote during an important shift in the order of European knowledge, this article explores two epistemological devices by which Mill consistently reconciled apparent outliers from a class to the rest of the class in question—his characterization of human differences as either “essential” or “accidental” and his reliance on a concept of the “norm” that is ambiguous between normative (ideal) and normal (typical) human character. Analyzing how Mill diminished both violence by the civilized and capacity for political change by barbarians as merely accidental, we can understand how epistemic and physical violence are linked and, more generally, how essentialism functions in the characterization of complex political phenomena.Keywords
This publication has 20 references indexed in Scilit:
- John Stuart Mill on ColoniesPolitical Theory, 2009
- Making Sense of Liberal Imperialism2007
- Barbarian thoughts: imperialism in the philosophy of John Stuart MillReview of International Studies, 2005
- John Stuart Mill's Asian ParableCanadian Journal of Political Science, 2001
- John Stuart Mill and the Ethic of Human Growth2001
- The Tree of Utility in India: Panace or Weed?1999
- The Moral Dimensions of J. S. Mill's ColonialismJournal of Social Philosophy, 1999
- J. S. Mill on Oriental Despotism, including its British VariantUtilitas, 1996
- John Stuart Mill: On Liberty and HistoryThe Western Political Quarterly, 1965
- John Stuart Mill's Theory of ProgressEthics, 1956