Abstract
A published article by Elizabeth Loftus and Melvin Guyer (2002) Loftus, E. F. and Guyer, M. J. 2002. Who abused Jane Doe?: The hazards of the single case study. Skeptical Inquirer, 26 May-June: 24–32. ibid., 2, 26 (July-August), 37-40, 44. [Google Scholar] examined the claim of a psychiatrist that “Jane Doe,” interviewed at age 5 and then 11 years later, had recovered a repressed memory of sexual abuse by her mother. The Loftus-Guyer article resulted in a lawsuit by the young woman who claimed invasions of privacy, defamation, and other injuries. This article details the history of the lawsuit and attends in particular to the tension between free speech as a scholarly right and the role of the courts and of Institutional Review Boards, both of which played a prominent role in regard to the research enterprise.