Trophic rewilding pumas and guanacos: estimating the potential to enhance carbon sequestration in a Patagonian grassland ecosystem
Preprint
Abstract
Trophic rewilding, the practice of restoring animal species to recover lost ecosystem functions, has been proposed as a nature-based climate change solution (NbCS) due to animal biogeochemical influences potentially extending to ecosystem carbon capture. We examined this potential using a case study of puma ( Puma concolor ) and guanaco ( Lama guanicoe ) restoration in a grassland ecosystem in Patagonia National Park, Chile. We parameterized a model of animal-driven ecosystem carbon dynamics with published measurements from Patagonian grasslands and compared three scenarios: (1) a no-rewilding baseline; (2) rewilding only guanaco; and (3) rewilding guanaco and puma. We estimated net primary productivity (NPP), net ecosystem carbon balance (NECB), and plant and soil carbon stocks. Using differences among scenarios, we estimated ecosystem carbon gains attributable to rewilding guanacos and pumas, and validated baseline estimates using published carbon capture data for Patagonian grasslands. Patagonian grasslands with pumas and guanacos could capture (NPP and NECB) 1.27–2.5 times more carbon, and increase plant carbon by 1.76–3.25 times, above the no-rewilding baseline. Large uncertainties in parameter values make estimating soil carbon challenging, but the rewilded ecosystem could store up to 1.16 times more soil carbon, or up to 0.57 times less. The model estimates that NECB in the rewilded ecosystem could amount to 94.41 t C km -2 y -1 (94.38 t C km -2 y -1 –94.44 t C km -2 y -1 ) of which 23%–43% attributable to animal effects. Plant carbon storage estimates were ∼290 t C km -2 (280–300 t C km -2 ), of which 43%–67% attributable to animal effects. Finally, the model estimated soil C stock gains up to 178 t C km -2 , or losses up to 4300 t C km -2 . Practical implications. We illustrate how to develop first approximation estimates of carbon capture and storage to help assess the feasibility of trophic rewilding as a NbCS. Our modelling revealed that restoring a puma-guanaco trophic cascade could be a feasible NbCS, and identified looming uncertainties about the fate of carbon that need further empirical exploration. More generally, the modelling identifies key measurements that can inform whether restoring trophic cascades can contribute to NbCS.Keywords
Funding Information
- Fundación Rewilding Chile
This publication has 44 references indexed in Scilit:
- Wolf reintroduction to Scotland could support substantial native woodland expansion and associated carbon sequestrationEcological Solutions and Evidence, 2025
- Trophic rewilding as a restoration approach under emerging novel biosphere conditionsCurrent Biology, 2024
- How do land cover changes affect carbon-nitrogen-phosphorus stocks and the greenhouse gas budget of ecosystems in southern Chile?Agriculture, Ecosystems & Environment, 2022
- Taxonomy, Distribution, and Conservation Status of Wild Guanaco Populations2022
- Guanaco Predation by Pumas and Its Relationship to Patagonian Food Webs2022
- Predator community composition is linked to soil carbon retention across a human land use gradientEcology, 2017
- Effects of gray wolf‐induced trophic cascades on ecosystem carbon cyclingEcosphere, 2016
- Soil enzyme and microbial activities in a grazing ecosystem of Patagonian Monte, ArgentinaGeoderma, 2011
- Leaf litterfall, fine-root production, and decomposition in shrublands with different canopy structure induced by grazing in the Patagonian Monte, ArgentinaPlant and Soil, 2008
- Carbon dioxide fluxes in a spatially and temporally heterogeneous temperate grasslandOecologia, 2005