Upper Jurassic Subsurface Cements

Author:

Abstract
Upper Smackover ooid grainstones, buried to depths of 3400 m across the central Gulf of Mexico, arc the hosts for Fe-zoned mosaic calcite and Fe-rich unzoned poikilitic calcite cements. These cements were precipitated into primary preserved pore space in a region where the only early diagenetic overprint was occasional marine cementation (Moore and Druckman, 1981). Petrography indicates that the zoned mosaic calcite cements were formed earlier than the unzoned poikilitic calcites, perhaps overlapping grain-to-grain pressure solution. The unzoned poikilitic calcites were precipitated after compaction and grain-to-grain pressure solution. Both cements contain two-phase fluid inclusions. Assuming the inclusions are primary, the zoned mosaic calcites formed under cooler and slightly less saline conditions than the poikilitic cements. The composition of the fluid phase in mixed zone mosaic and unzoned poikilitic cements at Walker Creek is similar in composition and salinity to present Smackover pore fluids (Klosterman, 1981). The trace element composition of both cement types is generally compatible with present Smackover brines, but because of natural water variation and uncertainties relative to distribution coefficients, these cements may have been precipitated by certain meteoric waters as well. Trace element composition of the mosaic calcite cement is significantly depleted in Mg, Fe and Mn relative to the poikilitic cement, supporting the petrographic and inclusion data, which suggest that the mosaic cement is younger. This relationship indicates that water composition evolved during the formation of the cements. The δ18O composition of the zoned mosaic calcites becomes progressively lighter from older to younger zones, indicating progressive temperature increase during burial formation, following the interpretation of Dickson and Coleman (1980). The δ18O composition of the poikilitic calcites (mean 6.4%c) is thought to indicate precipitation from Smackover-type brines under elevated temperatures (Moore and Druckman, 1981). Elevated levels of 87Sr/86Sr in the unzoned poikilitic cements tie these cements directly to present Smackover brines, which have high 87Sr/86Sr derived from mixing with siliciclastic-related fluids during early stages of hydrocarbon migration and shale dewatering. The identification of a specific water responsible for the poikilitic cements allows a revaluation of cement trace element composition, the calculation of paleotemperature of formation from δ18O composition of the cements, and an evaluation of the two-phase fluid inclusion data by comparison with the δ18O based paleotemperatures. The low Sr levels in the cements, in the face of elevated Sr/Ca of Smackover brines, call for reevaluation of Sr distribution coefficients under subsurface conditions. The Mg/Ca data indicate that Mg/Ca of the subsurface pore fluids has not evolved appreciably since burial, and supports Katz's (1973) distribution coefficient for Mg in calcite. Fe and Mn cement composition, when compared with the present brine composition indicates that the distribution coefficient for iron in calcite is greater than 1. This data also suggests (see also Michard, 1968), that the distribution coefficient for Mn in calcite probably increases with increasing temperature. Using the δ18O composition of the cements and the δ18O composition of present sea water in Friedman and O'Neil's expression (1977), the minimum temperature of formation for the poikilitic cements is 84°C, while the minimum temperature range of formation for the mosaic cements is from 42°C to 67°C, When isotopic data are compared with the two-phase fluid inclusion homogenization temperatures, the inclusion data yield consistently elevated temperatures. The poikilitic cements are closer to agreement than the mosaic calcites, suggesting that stepwise physical reequilibration of calcite two-phase fluid inclusions may be a problem. Using Nunn's (1984) Jurassic geothermal gradient, the poikilitic calcite cements are assumed to have formed after at least 1 km of burial, possibly during Lower Cretaceous Hosston time. This data effectively constrains the time of arrival of hydrocarbons into upper Jurassic reservoirs in the central Gulf to at least Lower Cretaceous Hosston time, since the poikilitic cements clearly formed prior to hydrocarbon arrival (Moore and Dmckman, 1981). The late poikilitic calcite cements are thought to be the result of regional subsurface dissolution of preexisting carbonates by siliciclastic-hydrocarbon related fluids, while the mosaic calcites are thought to be related to progressive grain-to-grain pressure solution.