Abstract
We measured oviposition preferences and offspring performance (survival of young larvae) within several populations of the butterfly Euphydryas editha. There was a significant association between speed of preference evolution and withinpopulation diversity of preference: preference ranks were more diverse within populations where preference was evolving rapidly than within ”stable” populations that were not undergoing rapid preference evolution. Preference rank was invariant within each “stable” population, even if the population used several host species. We suggest that, at least in E. editha, intrapopulation variability of preference rank only becomes apparent during episodes of rapid diet evolution. Preference rank was highly variable among populations, and is capable of rapid evolutionary change. In each “stable” population, the rank order of oviposition preference for different plant species was adaptive, being identical with the rank order of survival of newly hatched larvae experimentally placed on the same plant species in the field. In contrast, during the 1980s, most insects in each of the rapidly-evolving populations preferred to oviposit on their traditional host species, although offspring survival was higher on the novel host. Comparison with the set of “stable” populations suggests that this situation should be temporary, and it has proved to be so. In the 1990s, oviposition preference and offspring performance achieved concordance in both rapidly evolving populations. In one case, this resulted from evolution of preference, such that the suitable novel host became the most preferred at the population level. In the second, a dramatic reversal of the direction of selection occurred in 1992. Almost all the insects on the novel host were killed by a frost, while those on the traditional host were unaffected. The insects continued to prefer their traditional host and this preference became adaptive, at least temporarily.

This publication has 28 references indexed in Scilit: