Humanitized violence: Targeted killings and civilian deaths in the US war against the Islamic State
Author:
- 6 November 2018
- journal article
- research article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Current Sociology
- Vol. 67 (3) , 438-455
Abstract
Based on a qualitative content analysis of human rights reports, US military statements, and newspaper accounts, this article describes the ascendency of ‘humanitized violence,’ which characterizes airstrikes in the US war against the Islamic State (2014–2017). This hyper-rationalized violence utilizes precision weaponry, technical and administrative procedures to limit civilian deaths, and calculations to achieve goals in ‘proportionality.’ This method of violence is further accompanied by a discourse of precision, care, legality, and regret. The article further shows that leading nongovernmental critics of this violence largely accept its logic. Consequently, rather than offering opposition, humanitarian NGOs instead reinforce the humanitization of violence by calling on governments to be more precise and to exercise more care when striking enemy targets. Noting the high numbers of civilian deaths that can accompany humanitized violence, along with the US government’s continued capacity for total war, the author cautions that its rise does not necessarily portend a more peaceful future.Keywords
This publication has 19 references indexed in Scilit:
- “Its Own Kind of Torture”: Denial, Acknowledgment, and the Debate About Force Feeding at Guantánamo BaySociological Forum, 2017
- The Toxicity of Torture: The Cultural Structure of US Political Discourse of WaterboardingSocial Forces, 2014
- Hegemony and Humanitarian Norms: The U.S. Legitimation of Toxic ViolenceJournal of World-Systems Research, 2013
- Humanitarian Imperialism: The New Doctrine of Imperial RightMonthly Review, 2008
- Discursive Legacies: The U.S. Peace Movement and "Support the Troops"Social Problems, 2008
- Depoliticisation: Principles, Tactics and ToolsBritish Politics, 2006
- Qualitative Media Analysis1996
- Proportionality and Force in International LawAmerican Journal of International Law, 1993
- Reflections: Ethnographic content analysisQualitative Sociology, 1987
- Three faces of cruelty: Towards a comparative sociology of violenceTheory and Society, 1974