Improvement in volitional tests of muscle function alone may not be adequate evidence that inspiratory muscle training is effective
Authors:
- M.I. PolkeyMPM.I. Polkey
- J. MoxhamJMJ. Moxham
Open Access
- 1 January 2003
- journal article
- Published by European Respiratory Society (ERS) in European Respiratory Journal
- Vol. 23 (1) , 5-6
Abstract
In high income countries chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) is the most prevalent respiratory disability of adults 2. The maximal static inspiratory pressure (PI,max) is often reduced in patients with COPD 3, 4 and it is therefore unsurprising that various groups have sought to evaluate respiratory muscle training for such patients. However in the light of recent insights into diaphragm function in COPD the validity of this approach is not clear-cut. First, although PI,max is reduced this is mainly because of hyperinflation; when hyperinflation is discounted then in vivo diaphragm function is normal 5 or enhanced 6 in COPD. Second, despite early data on fatigue based on electromyographic studies, low frequency diaphragm fatigue is not associated with exercise intolerance 7, 8 or respiratory failure 9 in patients with COPD. Indeed the in vivo impression of fatigue resistance of the diaphragm in patients with COPD has been confirmed by the demonstration of cellular adaptations of this muscle in patients 10–13. In addition, before recommending such treatment to patients, one would also want evidence that inspiratory muscle training improves the contractile properties of the diaphragm. As far as the current authors are aware only one small study 14, from the present authors laboratory, has attempted to assess diaphragm contractility using phrenic nerve stimulation and, despite an improvement in PI,max the current authors were unable to detect any improvement in twitch transdiaphragmatic pressure. How did PI,max increase without improvement in diaphragm function; one answer could be because the subjects get better at “doing the test”. Certainly PI,max has been shown to increase substantially as a result of placebo treatment; for example Scherer et al. 15 found a 17.5% increase in PI,max in COPD patients allocated to control training. A biological explanation for this learning effect has recently emerged with the demonstration that the excitability of the area of the motor cortex representing the diaphragm can be increased by a course of inspiratory muscle training 16.Keywords
This publication has 18 references indexed in Scilit:
- Mitochondrial Electron Transport Chain Function Is Enhanced in Inspiratory Muscles of Patients with Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary DiseaseAmerican Journal of Respiratory and Critical Care Medicine, 2003
- Is Weaning Failure Caused by Low-Frequency Fatigue of the Diaphragm?American Journal of Respiratory and Critical Care Medicine, 2003
- Effects of controlled inspiratory muscle training in patients with COPD: a meta-analysisEuropean Respiratory Journal, 2002
- Bioenergetic adaptation of individual human diaphragmatic myofibers to severe COPDJournal of Applied Physiology, 2002
- Evaluation of an inspiratory muscle trainer in healthy humansRespiratory Medicine, 2001
- Global Strategy for the Diagnosis, Management, and Prevention of Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary DiseaseAmerican Journal of Respiratory and Critical Care Medicine, 2001
- Cellular Adaptations in the Diaphragm in Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary DiseaseNew England Journal of Medicine, 1997
- Inspiratory Muscle Training Combined with General Exercise Reconditioning in Patients with COPDChest, 1992
- Contractile Properties of the Human Diaphragm during Chronic HyperinflationNew England Journal of Medicine, 1991
- The thorax in chronic obstructive lung diseaseThe American Journal of Medicine, 1968