On (in)validating environmental models. 2. Implementation of a Turing‐like test to modelling hydrological processes
Open Access
- 11 October 2022
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wiley in Hydrological Processes
- Vol. 36 (10)
Abstract
Part 1 of this study discussed the concept of using a form of Turing‐like test for model evaluation, together with eight principles for implementing such an approach. In this part, the framing of fitness‐for‐purpose as a Turing‐like test is discussed, together with an example application of trying to assess whether a rainfall‐runoff model might be an adequate representation of the discharge response in a catchment for predicting future natural flood management scenarios. It is shown that the variation between event runoff coefficients in the record can be used to create some limits of acceptability that implicitly take some account of the epistemic uncertainties arising from lack of knowledge about errors in rainfall and discharge observations. In the case study it is demonstrated that the model used cannot be validated in this way across all the range of observed discharges, but that behavioural models can be found for the peak flows that are the subject of interest in the application. Thinking in terms of the Turing‐like test focusses attention on the critical observations needed to test whether streamflow is being produced in the right way so that a model is considered as fit‐for‐purpose in predicting the impacts of future change scenarios. As is the case for uncertainty estimation in general, it is argued that the assumptions made in setting behavioural limits of acceptability should be stated explicitly to leave an audit trail in any application that can be reviewed by users of the model outputs.Keywords
Funding Information
- Natural Environment Research Council (NE/R004722/1)
This publication has 118 references indexed in Scilit:
- Understanding predictive uncertainty in hydrologic modeling: The challenge of identifying input and structural errorsWater Resources Research, 2010
- A technique for the calibration of hydraulic models using uncertain satellite observations of flood extentJournal of Hydrology, 2009
- Towards a limits of acceptability approach to the calibration of hydrological models: Extending observation errorJournal of Hydrology, 2009
- Defining and classifying ecosystem services for decision makingEcological Economics, 2009
- Impact of biased and randomly corrupted inputs on the efficiency and the parameters of watershed modelsJournal of Hydrology, 2006
- Model Parameter Estimation Experiment (MOPEX): An overview of science strategy and major results from the second and third workshopsJournal of Hydrology, 2006
- A manifesto for the equifinality thesisJournal of Hydrology, 2006
- Identifiability of distributed floodplain roughness values in flood extent estimationJournal of Hydrology, 2005
- Functional classification and evaluation of hydrographs based on Multicomponent Mapping (Mx)International Journal of River Basin Management, 2004
- Validation of catchment models for predicting land-use and climate change impacts. 1. MethodJournal of Hydrology, 1996