SKML-Quality Mark for point-of-care test (POCT) glucose meters and glucose meters for home-use
Authors:
- 21 April 2010
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Walter de Gruyter GmbH in Clinical Chemistry and Laboratory Medicine (CCLM)
- Vol. 48 (7) , 1021-1027
Abstract
Background: Point-of-care glucose meters are used increasingly in semi- and non-professional context. The quality of glucose measurements depends on the quality of the equipment, the quality of use, and the pre-analytical conditions. In this article, a External Quality Assessment Scheme (SKML)-Quality Mark for point-of-care test (POCT) and self-test glucose meters is proposed, assessing analytical quality and technical quality. The analytical requirements are based on the biological variation concept, and a system to assess meters for the SKML-Quality Mark is described. Using the proposed system as an example, 14 meters were tested. Methods: The analytical quality of the POCT and self-test equipment was assessed for plasma calibrated glucose values by comparison with a trueness verified method traceable to the IFCC reference method in an accredited clinical laboratory. The concept is based on the biological variation system. The SKML-Quality Mark comprises the following criteria for blood glucose equipment: 1) Fulfilment of compliance with ISO 15197 and/or TNO guideline criterion; 2) Fulfilment of the total allowable error (TAE) criterion; 3) Fulfilment of the total allowable linearity bias criterion; 4) Fulfilment of the total allowable interfering substances bias criterion; and 5) Fulfilment of the haematocrit criterion. Results: The proposed SKML-Quality Mark system was tested on 14 commercial home-use meters. The TAE criterion is violated by two meters. The main reason for the violation is bias. For the majority of meters, the Passing and Bablok regression confidence interval does not include the intercept of 0.0 and slope of 1.0. In addition, Syx indicates dispersion around the line or non-linearity. The bias and total error at three different concentrations were investigated as part of the quality mark, resulting in disapproval of the Dicomed Sensocard Plus meter. The bias was significant for the Wellion Linus. With respect to interfering substances, bias of the same magnitude and sign as the bias without additive was seen for all meters for acetaminophen, indicating no additional interference. For ascorbic acid, an additional bias was seen for several meters. However, significant bias was demonstrated for the Sensocard Plus and Glucocard X-meter. Conclusions: The biological variation concept offers a scientific basis for assessment of acceptable deviation. The concept is extended in the SKML-Quality Mark correcting for the limited number of measurements that can be performed while assessing home-use or POCT meters. The results show that three out of 14 meters fail the proposed quality mark. Clin Chem Lab Med 2010;48:1021–7.Keywords
This publication has 4 references indexed in Scilit:
- External Quality Assessment in The Netherlands: time to introduce commutable survey specimens. Lessons from the Dutch “Calibration 2000” projectClinical Chemistry and Laboratory Medicine (CCLM), 2005
- Effects of Drugs on Glucose Measurements With Handheld Glucose Meters and a Portable Glucose AnalyzerAmerican Journal of Clinical Pathology, 2000
- Recommendations of the German Working Group on Medical Laboratory Testing (AML) on the Introduction and Quality Assurance of Procedures for Point-of-Care Testing (POCT) in HospitalsClinical Chemistry and Laboratory Medicine (CCLM), 1999
- Current databases on biological variation: pros, cons and progressScandinavian Journal of Clinical and Laboratory Investigation, 1999