Evaluation of enteric methane prediction equations for dairy cows used in whole farm models
- 3 November 2010
- journal article
- Published by Wiley in Global Change Biology
- Vol. 16 (12) , 3246-3256
Abstract
The importance of evaluating greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions from dairy cows within the whole farm setting is being realized as more important than evaluating these emissions in isolation. Current whole farm models aimed at evaluating GHG emissions make use of simple regression equations to predict enteric methane (CH4) production. The objective of the current paper is to evaluate the performance of nine CH4 prediction equations that are currently being used in whole farm GHG models. Data used to evaluate the prediction equations came from a collection of individual (IND) and treatment averaged (TRT) data. Equations were compared based on mean square prediction error (MSPE) and concordance correlation coefficient (CCC) analysis. In general, predictions were poor, with root MSPE (as a percentage of observed mean) values ranging from 20.2 to 52.5 for the IND database and from 24.0 to 38.2 for the TRT database and CCC values ranging from 0.009 to 0.493 for the IND database and from 0.000 to 0.271 for the TRT database. Overall, the equations of Moe & Tyrrell and IPCC Tier II performed best on the IND dataset, and the equations of Moe & Tyrrell and Kirchgeßner et al., performed best on the TRT dataset. Results show that the simple more generalized equations performed worse than those that attempted to represent important aspects of diet composition, but in general significant amounts of bias and deviation of the regression slope from unity existed for all equations. The low prediction accuracy of CH4 equations in whole farm models may introduce substantial error into inventories of GHG emissions and lead to incorrect mitigation recommendations.Keywords
This publication has 41 references indexed in Scilit:
- Methane output and diet digestibility in response to feeding dairy cows crude linseed, extruded linseed, or linseed oil1Journal of Animal Science, 2008
- Aspects of rumen microbiology central to mechanistic modelling of methane production in cattleThe Journal of Agricultural Science, 2008
- Data capture: development of a mobile open-circuit ventilated hood system for measuring real-time gaseous emissions in cattle.2008
- A review of farm level modelling approaches for mitigating greenhouse gas emissions from ruminant livestock systemsLivestock Science, 2007
- Predicting the profile of nutrients available for absorption: from nutrient requirement to animal response and environmental impactAnimal, 2007
- Effect of improved nitrogen management on greenhouse gas emissions from intensive dairy systems in the NetherlandsGlobal Change Biology, 2006
- Estimation of the stoichiometry of volatile fatty acid production in the rumen of lactating cowsJournal of Theoretical Biology, 2006
- Effect of the Carbohydrate Composition of feed Concentratates on Methane Emission from dairy Cows and Their SlurryEnvironmental Monitoring and Assessment, 2005
- Mitigation strategies to reduce enteric methane emissions from dairy cows: Update reviewCanadian Journal of Animal Science, 2004
- Metabolism of the lactating cow: II. Digestive elements of a mechanistic modelJournal of Dairy Research, 1987