Abstract
The Liberal Party’s suite of policies to manage the arrival of people seeking asylum by boat is one of the party’s defining policy platforms of the 21st century. Arguably, it is a policy over which the party has the most comprehensive control over the narrative, debates, and policy outcomes; and this is true even from opposition. This chapter tells the story of the evolution of the Liberal Party’s dominance over asylum policy. 2001 was a watershed year, when John Howard’s response to the MV Tampa and the Children Overboard Affair introduced the notion into Australian politics that being tough on asylum seekers wins elections. This idea has persisted, and over the next quarter century the Liberal Party’s approach to asylum seekers has been described as policy ratchetting: ever more militarised and harsh. Since 2010, Liberal MPs who proved their mettle on asylum policy have been rewarded with promotion to party leadership. Subsequently, the ‘hard man’ approach required to ‘stop the boats’ has forged a particular character of Liberal leaders in the 21st century. While achieving total control over the borders is not realistic, the Liberal Party has sought to gain total control over the narrative about people seeking asylum. The Labor government is unable to prosecute an alternative approach, and on this policy area remains perennially vulnerable. This political story of the Liberal Party’s control over asylum policy persists, despite the policies themselves failing on multiple democratic, human rights, and international relations measures.