In the face of competition, imperfect knowledge can lead to sustainable exploitation of a shared resource
Authors:
- Geert AartsGAGeert Aarts
- John R. FiebergJFJohn R. Fieberg
- Andries RichterARAndries Richter
- Jan Jaap PoosJPJan Jaap Poos
- Niels T. HintzenNHNiels T. Hintzen
- Allert Imre BijleveldABAllert Imre Bijleveld
- Geerten M. HengeveldGHGeerten M. Hengeveld
- Tobias van KootenTKTobias van Kooten
- Anieke van LeeuwenALAnieke van Leeuwen
- Jason MatthiopoulosJMJason Matthiopoulos
- Frank van LangeveldeFLFrank van Langevelde
- Louise Riotte-LambertLRLouise Riotte-Lambert
Preprint
Abstract
Overexploitation of a shared resource is a frequent phenomenon among groups of selfish consumers, known as the ‘tragedy of the commons’. To avoid “self-damage through self-interest”, humans may either defend exclusive access to resources, or collectively adopt advanced cooperative behaviour and carefully designed spatial harvesting strategies to exploit a shared resource sustainably. However, why do many non-human species that are neither social nor territorial also appear to avoid overexploiting resources? This study shows that, even under highly competitive scenarios, cooperation is not necessary to sustainably exploit shared resources if individuals have imperfect knowledge about the distribution of those resources. Poorly informed individuals are more likely to inadvertently exploit resources in peripheral habitats, which may allow for higher resource renewal in the nearby and low-cost habitats, enhancing the sustainability of resource use. As a result, those consumers can achieve a long-term yield that approaches that of cooperative consumers and is higher than omniscient consumers. Ironically, while there might be an evolutionary drive for individuals to make well-informed decisions, consumers of shared resources may be collectively more prosperous when they make decisions based on less information. These findings might explain why apparently sub-optimal consumer behaviour appears so prevalent in nature.Keywords
This publication has 62 references indexed in Scilit:
- Sustaining local commons in the face of uncertain ecological thresholds: Evidence from a framed field experiment with Colombian small-scale fishersEcological Economics, 2023
- Suboptimal foraging theory: How inaccurate predictions and approximations can make better models of adaptive behaviorEcology, 2022
- The World’s Future Crisis: Extractive Resources Depletion2021
- Toward reliable habitat suitability and accessibility models in an era of multiple environmental stressorsEcology and Evolution, 2020
- Side‐swiped: ecological cascades emanating from earthworm invasionsFrontiers in Ecology and the Environment, 2019
- The Impact of Resource Uncertainty and Intergroup Conflict on Harvesting in the Common-Pool Resource ExperimentEnvironmental and Resource Economics, 2017
- Dynamic patterns of overexploitation in fisheriesEcological Modelling, 2017
- When animals misbehave: Analogs of human biases and suboptimal choiceBehavioural Processes, 2015
- The effect of environmental uncertainty on the tragedy of the commonsGames and Economic Behavior, 2013
- Ontogenetic Scaling of Foraging Rates and the Dynamics of a Size-Structured Consumer-Resource ModelTheoretical Population Biology, 1998