Applying DOE in Performance Optimization of an Automated Position Control System - A Collaborated Case Study between Two Engineering Technology Courses
Electrohydraulic systems with the combination of hydraulic hardware and electronics have offered superior industrial applications in position, velocity, and force/torque control. Position control is the more demanding applications of such automated electrohydraulic systems. However, the system performance is affected by many factors in such a complicated system with hydraulic hardware, electronic hardware and software, and therefore impacts the process and product quality. To improve the efficiency of system optimization, it is important to identify the key factors that play significant roles in system performance. The case study presented here is to apply methodology of the Design of Experiments students learned from a quality management course in the control system established in their hydraulic course to identify the key factors for system optimization. The purpose of the case study is for students to learn and practice problem solving by applying knowledge and skills from two different courses. Students can design the process in problem solving as they would in real world. The purpose of the case study is to answer the questions: Which parameter(s) affect the system performance and to what extent? And can optimal settings be identified for the system to perform consistently? In the case study, students will identify the key factors in affecting the system performance of an automated electrohydraulic position control system. The process studied here is the position control of a hydraulic cylinder through a PID controller. The system is composed of a hydraulic cylinder, a servo valve, a PID controller, and a position sensor. The performance measures of the system are response time of the cylinder to a target setpoint position, and positioning errors that reflect the deviation of current cylinder position from the target position. The controllable process parameters are identified as the control gains of the PID controller and the system pressure. The control gains of the controller include the P value (proportional gain), the I value (integral gain), and the D value (differential gain). Students will apply DOE method on the system analysis to identify the optimized setting for position control. The DOE design, measurements, and experimental runs will be demonstrated and explained. The impact on students’ understanding of the method and system will be analyzed through assessment of their report and presentation.