THEORETICAL PERSPECTIVES ON APPROACHES TO POLICY EVALUATION IN THE EU: THE CASE OF COHESION POLICY
Authors:
- 13 January 2012
- journal article
- Published by Wiley in Public Administration
- Vol. 90 (3) , 699-715
Abstract
Cohesion Policy accounts for the largest area of expenditure in the EU budget. Because of its scope and redistributive nature, evaluation is particularly important. Policy analysis tends to overlook the evaluation stage. Few empirical studies seek to apply theory to EU policy evaluation. This article questions the relevance and usefulness of theorizing evaluation practice, exploring positivist, realist, and constructivist perspectives upon approaches to evaluating Structural Funds Programmes. It illustrates how political science theories can provide scholars with useful insights into the way EU policy evaluation is carried out. It develops a toolkit for analyzing real‐world approaches to evaluation and then applies it to three separate Cohesion Policy programmes. The analysis shows how, from a theoretical perspective – and contrary to the mixed methods rhetoric of the European Commission – positivism remains the dominant approach when evaluating the Structural Funds and considers why this is so, identifying the ability to demonstrate efficiency and effectiveness, cost, influence, and evaluation culture as key characteristics.Keywords
This publication has 17 references indexed in Scilit:
- Cohesion or Confusion: A Policy Searching for ObjectivesJournal of European Integration, 2010
- Impact of Objective 1 Funds on Regional Growth Convergence in the European Union: A Panel-data ApproachRegional Studies, 2008
- Co-managing programme implementation: conceptualizing the European Commission's role in policy executionJournal of European Public Policy, 2006
- Evaluation of European Union Cohesion policy: Research questions and policy challengesRegional Studies, 2006
- Structural funds and the evaluation of community economic development initiatives in the UK: A critical perspectiveRegional Studies, 2006
- Strengths and weaknesses of European Union policy evaluation methods:Ex-postevaluation of objective 2, 1994–99Regional Studies, 2006
- Case Study Research2006
- The EU ‘partnership principle’: still a sustainable governance device across multiple administrative arenas?Public Administration, 2002
- Realism and International Relations2000
- Beyond Empiricism: Policy Inquiry in Post positivist PerspectivePolicy Studies Journal, 1998