The use of EU soft law by national courts and bureaucrats: how relation to hard law and policy maturity matter
- 23 March 2020
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in West European Politics
- Vol. 44 (1) , 134-154
Abstract
Soft law instruments account for a sizable share of EU legal acts, with growing importance over time. Yet, while the implementation of hard EU law has been widely studied, little is known about the use of EU soft law at the national level. In the article, it is firstly argued that the type of soft law instrument will affect national usage. Administrators and judges may welcome interpretative guidelines to complicated pieces of legislation, while more open-ended instruments may be ignored. It is further argued that the maturity of the policy field matters. National actors in mature policy fields will be routinely exposed to EU rules and they are socialized into responding to impulses from Brussels. The article probes the plausibility of these expectations in case studies on the use of EU soft law instruments by German administrations and courts in four policy fields: financial market regulation, competition, environmental protection and social policy.Keywords
This publication has 18 references indexed in Scilit:
- The Open Method of Coordination on Pensions: Does it De-politicise Pensions Policy?West European Politics, 2009
- Embracing European LawEuropean Union Politics, 2008
- On Government, Governance and Judicial Review: The Case of European Competition PolicyJournal of Public Policy, 2008
- Transcending the Goodness of FitComparative European Politics, 2007
- Worlds of compliance: Why leading approaches to European Union implementation are only ‘sometimes‐true theories’European Journal of Political Research, 2007
- Pincers and Prestige: Explaining the Implementation of EU Gender Equality LegislationComparative European Politics, 2005
- Legal Instruments in European Union Law and Their Reform: A Systematic Approach on an Empirical BasisYearbook of European Law, 2004
- The Europeanization of National Government and Policy: A Departmental PerspectiveBritish Journal of Political Science, 2003
- The soft law approach: Commission rule-making in the EU's state aid regimeJournal of European Public Policy, 2001
- European integration and national executives: A cause in search of an effect?West European Politics, 2000