Too Much, Too Little and Too Often: A Critique of du Gay's Analysis of Enterprise
Authors:
- 1 February 1999
- journal article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Organization
- Vol. 6 (1) , 107-128
Abstract
In recent years, organizational and political debates have accorded a privileged position to enterprise as holding the promise for both corporate and individual development. In several publications, Paul du Gay has articulated a persuasive analysis and critique of the enterprise discourse; he and a number of collaborators have analysed the various managerial discourses and techniques through which employees are reimagined as entrepreneurs, and organizations are to move from dysfunctional bureaucracies to models of excellence. Whilst we share du Gay's critical position towards enterprise and the Foucauldian tradition upon which he draws, we feel that his analysis suffers from several flaws which we articulate around three themes. Firstly, we argue that du Gay's analysis claims too much for enterprise, and relies on a flawed dualism between enterprise and bureaucracy; secondly, we feel that his analysis is over-deterministic and makes too little space for resistance and alternative discourses to enterprise; finally, we suggest that du Gay has presented the same arguments too often and that his work is implicated in the constitution of the enterprise discourse as an accomplished fact within the academic community.Keywords
This publication has 30 references indexed in Scilit:
- Towards A Critique of Managerialism: the Contribution of Simone Weil*Journal of Management Studies, 1996
- REDISCOVERING HEGEL: THE ‘NEW HISTORICISM’ IN ORGANIZATION AND MANAGEMENT STUDIESJournal of Management Studies, 1996
- Managerialism and the legal profession: A new professional paradigmInternational Journal of the Legal Profession, 1995
- Entrepreneurial Management in the Public SectorWork, Employment and Society, 1993
- THE CULT[URE] OF THE CUSTOMERJournal of Management Studies, 1992
- Political Power beyond the State: Problematics of GovernmentThe British Journal of Sociology, 1992
- The Myth of Post‐Fordist Management: Work Organization and Employee Discretion in Seven CountriesEmployee Relations: The International Journal, 1992
- New Wave Management?Work, Employment and Society, 1989
- New Production Arrangements: The Totally Flexible Cage?Work, Employment and Society, 1989
- Toward a Marxist Theory of the Labor Process: Braverman and BeyondPolitics & Society, 1978