Marx, discourse theory and political analysis: negotiating an ambiguous legacy
Author:
- 8 April 2018
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Critical Discourse Studies
- Vol. 15 (4) , 377-389
Abstract
This article argues that ‘post-Marxist’ or ‘poststructuralist discourse theory’ represents a complex deconstruction of the Marxist tradition of social and political theory. Focussing on three ontological positions in Marx’s texts – the ontologies of human alienation, praxis, and production – the article shows how this approach repeats and transforms the rich tradition of Marxist thinking so as to elaborate a novel approach to social and political analysis. This claim is built around the idea that discourse is best conceptualized as an ‘articulatory practice’, whose elements are both linguistic and non-linguistic in character, and whose products are finite relational orders, including social institutions and economic processes. The result is (1) a shift away from economic determinism and class reductionism to a relational account of social and political forms; (2) the development of an anti-essentialist and anti-reductionist account of political identities, which emerge in a dialectical tension with incomplete processes of identification, and (3) a particular understanding of the subject and agency in political theory, which grounds a different account of political practices. The article also (4) sets out the methodological implications of post-Marxist discourse theory, which is focussed on the articulation of different logics of critical explanation, before (5) exploring the role of critique and normativity in this approach, which are conceptualized as continuous, immanent and complex.Keywords
This publication has 8 references indexed in Scilit:
- Discourse analysis as immanent critique: Possibilities and limits of normative critique in empirical discourse studiesDiscourse & Society, 2016
- Political Discourse Analysis2013
- Poststructuralism and After2013
- The Discourse of Politics in Action2009
- Discourse and Power2008
- Logics of Critical Explanation in Social and Political Theory2007
- The grip of ideology: A Lacanian approach to the theory of ideologyJournal of Political Ideologies, 2001
- Reflections on violence1999