Quantifying the diagnostic time gap in precision oncology: A retrospective analysis of potential time savings from same-day cartridge-based molecular testing versus next-generation sequencing in cytology specimens
Open Access
- 16 October 2026
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Public Library of Science (PLoS) in PLOS ONE
- Vol. 21 (10) , e0360239
Abstract
Background: Next-generation sequencing (NGS) turnaround times (TAT) exceed two weeks and can delay the initiation of targeted therapy. Rapid cartridge-based platforms such as Idylla deliver single-gene or fusion results from minimal cytology material within hours, but time savings have not been systematically quantified. Methods: Forty-two cases of non-small cell lung carcinoma, thyroid carcinoma, melanoma, and mammary analogue secretory carcinoma of the salivary gland that underwent both Idylla testing ( KRAS , EGFR , BRAF, and GeneFusion assays) and orthogonal NGS at a single academic center were reviewed. NGS TAT was calculated from specimen collection to report release, and Idylla results were modeled as available one day after collection. The primary outcome was per-case time savings (NGS TAT minus one day); treatment timelines were reconstructed from the medical record. Analyses were descriptive; no inferential testing was performed. A sensitivity analysis varied the modeled Idylla TAT from 1 to 3 days, and an adjusted estimate assigned no time saving to the two cartridge results that were not actionable on the day of collection. Results: The median NGS TAT across all 42 cases was 20.0 days (IQR, 17.0–23.8; range, 8–51). Against the modeled 1-day Idylla TAT, the median time savings was 19.0 days per case (IQR, 16.0–22.8; range, 7–50), totaling 858 patient-days. Assigning no time saving to those two cases gave a median of 18.0 days and 817 patient-days. No patient received therapy that was subsequently contradicted by the sequencing result. In thirteen patients, the sequencing interval alone exceeded three weeks, and in seven, no systemic therapy was underway while the result was awaited. Conclusions: Same-day cartridge-based testing from cytology and small biopsy specimens could provide actionable results a median of 19 days earlier than standard NGS. Whether this translates into earlier treatment initiation was not assessed and requires prospective evaluation.Keywords
This publication has 29 references indexed in Scilit:
- Ultrarapid EGFR Testing in Non–Small Cell Lung Carcinoma Patients: Findings From a Canadian Clinical Testing WorkflowLaboratory Investigation, 2025
- Adverse effects of health plan prior authorization on clinical effectiveness and patient outcomes: A systematic reviewThe American Journal of Medicine, 2025
- Diagnostic accuracy of the Idylla™ mutation test for detecting EGFR mutations in non-small cell lung cancer: a meta-analysisLung Cancer, 2025
- Same‐day molecular testing for targetable mutations in solid tumor cytopathology—The next frontier of the rapid on‐site evaluationCancer Cytopathology, 2025
- A rapid turnaround time workflow for a cytological liquid biopsy assay using FNA supernatant specimensCancer Cytopathology, 2024
- Assessing the Cost-Effectiveness of Next-Generation Sequencing as a Biomarker Testing Approach in Oncology and Policy Implications: A Literature ReviewValue in Health, 2024
- Pathologist-initiated reflex testing for biomarkers in non-small-cell lung cancer: expert consensus on the rationale and considerations for implementationESMO Open, 2023
- Feasibility and performance of the Idylla™ NRAS/BRAF cartridge mutation assay on thyroid liquid‐based fine‐needle aspirationDiagnostic Cytopathology, 2021
- Rapid On‐site Molecular Evaluation in thyroid cytopathology: A same‐day cytological and molecular diagnosisDiagnostic Cytopathology, 2020
- Updated Molecular Testing Guideline for the Selection of Lung Cancer Patients for Treatment With Targeted Tyrosine Kinase InhibitorsJournal of Thoracic Oncology, 2018