Abstract
In Australia immigration department decisions regarding refugee status applications are reviewable at an independent merits review tribunal, the Refugee Review Tribunal (the ‘Tribunal’). This paper examines the Tribunal's approach to the assessment of applicants' credibility. A series of decisions by the Tribunal in which credibility figured significantly were considered in order to identify both the source of the credibility evidence adduced and the place the evidence had in the decision. Credibility evidence is derived from a variety of sources which vary in their reliability and probative value. It is argued that in its weighing of evidence the Tribunal does not adequately acknowledge the variable quality of credibility evidence. When adverse credibility findings are reached by the Tribunal, applicants face considerable obstacles in restoring their credibility. Adverse credibility findings are both difficult to rebut and an infrequent ground for successful judicial review, the assessment of credibility falling squarely within the Tribunal's prescribed role of fact finding and apportioning of weight to evidence. Consequently, quite apart from the severe statutory restrictions now existing on the judicial review of the Tribunal's decisions, the judiciary has a limited if still important role in overseeing the Tribunal's approach to credibility. It is argued that guidelines directed at the shortcomings in the Tribunal's assessment and weighing of credibility would promote the fairness and quality of the Tribunal's decisions.