Using Self-reports or Claims to Assess Disease Prevalence
- 1 August 2017
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wolters Kluwer Health in Medical Care
- Vol. 55 (8) , 782-788
Abstract
Background: Two common ways of measuring disease prevalence include: (1) using self-reported disease diagnosis from survey responses; and (2) using disease-specific diagnosis codes found in administrative data. Because they do not suffer from self-report biases, claims are often assumed to be more objective. However, it is not clear that claims always produce better prevalence estimates. Objective: Conduct an assessment of discrepancies between self-report and claims-based measures for 2 diseases in the US elderly to investigate definition, selection, and measurement error issues which may help explain divergence between claims and self-report estimates of prevalence. Data: Self-reported data from 3 sources are included: the Health and Retirement Study, the Medicare Current Beneficiary Survey, and the National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey. Claims-based disease measurements are provided from Medicare claims linked to Health and Retirement Study and Medicare Current Beneficiary Survey participants, comprehensive claims data from a 20% random sample of Medicare enrollees, and private health insurance claims from Humana Inc. Methods: Prevalence of diagnosed disease in the US elderly are computed and compared across sources. Two medical conditions are considered: diabetes and heart attack. Results: Comparisons of diagnosed diabetes and heart attack prevalence show similar trends by source, but claims differ from self-reports with regard to levels. Selection into insurance plans, disease definitions, and the reference period used by algorithms are identified as sources contributing to differences. Conclusions: Claims and self-reports both have strengths and weaknesses, which researchers need to consider when interpreting estimates of prevalence from these 2 sources.Keywords
This publication has 21 references indexed in Scilit:
- New Risk-Adjustment System Was Associated With Reduced Favorable Selection In Medicare AdvantageHealth Affairs, 2012
- Does Cognitive Ability Explain Inaccuracy in Older Adults’ Self-Reported Medication Adherence?Journal of Applied Gerontology, 2009
- Identification of Dementia: Agreement among National Survey Data, Medicare Claims, and Death CertificatesHealth Services Research, 2007
- Hospital Episodes and Physician VisitsMedical Care, 2007
- Validity of gout diagnoses in administrative dataArthritis Care & Research, 2007
- Data Sources for Measuring ComorbidityMedical Care, 2006
- Failure of ICD‐9‐CM Codes to Identify Patients with Comorbid Chronic Kidney Disease in DiabetesHealth Services Research, 2005
- Specificity and Sensitivity of Claims‐Based Algorithms for Identifying Members of Medicare+Choice Health Plans That Have Chronic Medical ConditionsHealth Services Research, 2004
- Agreement between Self-Reported Information and Medical Claims Data on Diagnosed Diabetes in Oregonʼs Medicaid PopulationJournal of Public Health Management & Practice, 2003
- The Validity of Self-reported Physician Utilization MeasuresMedical Care, 1984