Abstract
When a cell's environment changes, a large transcriptional response often takes place. The exquisite sensitivity and specificity of these responses are controlled in large part by the combinations of cis ‐regulatory elements that reside in gene promoters and adjacent control regions. Here, we present a study aimed at accurately modeling the relationship between combinations of cis ‐regulatory elements and the expression levels they drive in different environments. We constructed four libraries of synthetic promoters in yeast, consisting of combinations of transcription factor binding sites and assayed their expression in four different environments. Thermodynamic models relating promoter sequences to their corresponding four expression levels explained at least 56% of the variation in expression in each library through the different conditions. Analyses of these models suggested that a large fraction of regulated gene expression is explained by changes in the effective concentration of sequence‐specific transcription factors, and we show that in most cases, the corresponding transcription factors are expressed in a pattern that is predicted by the thermodynamic models. Our analysis uncovered two binding sites that switch from activators to repressors in different environmental conditions. In both the cases, the switch was not the result of a single transcription factor changing regulatory modes, but most likely due to competition between multiple factors binding to the same site. Our analysis suggests that this mode of regulation allows for large and steep changes in expression in response to changing transcription factor concentrations. Our results demonstrate that many complex changes in gene expression are accurately explained by simple changes in the effective concentrations of transcription factors. ### Synopsis When a cell's environment changes, a large transcriptional response often takes place. These responses facilitate cellular processes such as differentiation ([Gardner and Barald, 1991][1]), proliferation ([Radinsky, 1995][2]), cellular defense ([Owuor and Kong, 2002][3]), and apoptosis ([Matikainen et al , 2001][4]). Multiple transcription factors (TF) orchestrate an environment‐induced transcriptional response and, therefore, the response of an individual gene depends on the combination of TF binding sites present in its promoter. To understand how the expression of individual genes change in response to environmental perturbations, the impact of combinations of binding sites on expression in different environments needs to be elucidated. To study combinatorial gene regulation in different environments, we constructed large libraries of synthetic promoters in yeast comprised of random combinations of TF binding sites. We determined each promoter's combination of binding sites and measured each promoter's expression output in four different environments. We then attempted to create a mathematical model that could relate combinations of TF binding sites to expression levels. We found that simple thermodynamic models ([Shea and Ackers, 1985][5]) that take into account changes in effective TF concentrations were able to explain most of the variation in expression created by different combinations of binding sites in different environments. The thermodynamic models make predictions about the relative TF concentrations in the different environments. We found that for the majority of TFs tested, the expression pattern of the TF matched well with predictions based on the model. These results indicate that environment‐specific expression is primarily driven by changes in TF concentrations. We also uncovered two TF binding sites that switch from activators to repressors in different environments. In both cases, we found that one single TF was not responsible for the switch; therefore, the binding site switching was not the result of a TF changing modes from an activator to a repressor. The most likely explanation is competition for a single site by two TFs (an activator and a repressor). We modified the thermodynamic models to allow for competing factors and found that adding competing factors made the models significantly more accurate. The approach of building and analyzing combinatorial synthetic promoters has allowed us to gain insight into the mechanism of environment‐specific gene regulation. Overall, we discovered that fairly simple rules underlie the relationship between combinations of TF binding sites in environment‐specific expression. These simple rules, however, can create complex patterns of gene regulation, including the switching of binding sites from activators to repressors. Mol Syst Biol. 5: 244 [1]: #ref-9 [2]: #ref-30 [3]: #ref-26 [4]: #ref-23 [5]: #ref-35