Balancing Layout Space and Risk Comprehension in Health Communication: A Comparison of Separated and Integrated Icon Arrays
Open Access
- 30 September 2025
- journal article
- research article
- Published by MDPI AG in Informatics
- Vol. 12 (4) , 105
Abstract
This study investigated how icon array layouts influence comprehension of medical risk information, particularly in relation to users’ cognitive abilities. In a within-subjects experiment (N = 121), participants reviewed clinical scenarios with treatment-related risks and side effect risks displayed in either separated or integrated icon arrays. Comprehension was significantly higher for separated treatment-related risk layouts (p < 0.001), while side effect layout showed no effect. Numeracy and graph literacy significantly predicted comprehension. Crucially, individuals with lower numeracy showed marked gains when viewing separated formats, whereas those with higher numeracy performed well regardless of layout. Despite this, participants preferred hybrid formats—separated treatment-related risk with integrated side effect risks—revealing a critical preference–performance gap. By demonstrating how visual layout interacts with user abilities, this study provides actionable guidance for patient decision aid design. The findings show that comprehension accuracy must take precedence over layout compactness and user preference, with separated layouts recommended for treatment-related risks—especially for individuals with lower numeracy—and greater flexibility allowed for side effect risks when space is limited.Keywords
This publication has 35 references indexed in Scilit:
- Numeracy levels influence shared decision-making and surgical outcomes: A scoping review of the literatureThe American Journal of Surgery, 2023
- Improving Physician Communication About Treatment DecisionsJAMA, 2020
- Availability of patient decision aids for stroke prevention in atrial fibrillation: A systematic reviewAmerican Heart Journal, 2017
- Individual Differences in Graph Literacy: Overcoming Denominator Neglect in Risk ComprehensionJournal of Behavioral Decision Making, 2011
- Improving understanding of adjuvant therapy options by using simpler risk graphicsCancer, 2008
- Communicating side effect risks in a tamoxifen prophylaxis decision aid: The debiasing influence of pictographsPatient Education and Counseling, 2008
- Shared Decision MakingHave We Missed the Obvious?Archives of internal medicine (1960), 2008
- Validation of Screening Questions for Limited Health Literacy in a Large VA Outpatient PopulationJournal of General Internal Medicine, 2008
- Communicating risk information: The influence of graphical display format on quantitative information perception—Accuracy, comprehension and preferencesPatient Education and Counseling, 2007
- Developmental Increase in Working Memory Span: Resource Sharing or Temporal Decay?Journal of Memory and Language, 2001