Appropriateness Criteria Are an Imprecise Measure for Repeat Echocardiograms
- 7 January 2011
- journal article
- Published by Wiley in Echocardiography
- Vol. 28 (2) , 131-135
Abstract
Previous studies have reported that most transthoracic echocardiograms meet current ACC/ASE appropriateness criteria, but efficacy of appropriateness criteria for repeat echocardiograms has not been investigated. We sought to prospectively determine whether current appropriateness criteria accurately assess the need for repeat echocardiograms in a consecutive series of inpatients in a tertiary care community teaching hospital. Appropriateness criteria were assessed for consecutive echocardiograms ordered over 30 days. Ordering clinician specialty and level of training were recorded. For repeat echocardiograms, change in clinical status between first and second echocardiogram and any change in echocardiographic findings were documented. Out of 574 echocardiograms analyzed, 143 repeat studies were performed in 104 patients. Level of appropriateness for first time studies was estimated at 84.6% and for repeat studies at 73.4% (x(2) = 7.71, P = 0.005). Of those patients receiving at least 1 repeat echocardiogram 42 patients (40%) experienced no detectable change in clinical status or other reason that would justify a repeat study. New echocardiographic findings were found in slightly more than half (52%) of patients receiving repeat studies. Inappropriate repeat echocardiograms are ordered more frequently than first time studies. A significant proportion of repeat echocardiograms do not appear to be justified, and often yield no new echocardiographic findings. Our data suggest that current appropriateness criteria might benefit from further revision with particular regard to justification for repeat studies.Keywords
This publication has 12 references indexed in Scilit:
- Use and Appropriateness of Transthoracic Echocardiography in an Academic Medical Center: A Pilot Observational StudyJournal of the American Society of Echocardiography, 2009
- Application of Appropriateness Criteria in Outpatient Transthoracic EchocardiographyJournal of the American Society of Echocardiography, 2009
- Prospective Evaluation of the Clinical Application of the American College of Cardiology Foundation/American Society of Echocardiography Appropriateness Criteria for Transthoracic EchocardiographyJACC: Cardiovascular Imaging, 2008
- Influencing Behavior of Physicians Ordering Laboratory TestsMedical Care, 1993
- Changing physician test ordering in a university hospital. An intervention of physician participation, explicit criteria, and feedbackArchives of internal medicine (1960), 1989
- Modifying test-ordering behavior in the outpatient medical clinic. A controlled trial of two educational interventionsArchives of internal medicine (1960), 1985
- A Review of Physician Cost-Containment Strategies for Laboratory TestingMedical Care, 1983
- A Trial of Two Strategies to Modify the Test-Ordering Behavior of Medical ResidentsNew England Journal of Medicine, 1980
- Why do physicians order laboratory tests? A study of laboratory test request and use patterns1980
- To Be CompleteNew England Journal of Medicine, 1979