Untangling Self‐Blame and Mother‐Blame in Women's and Children's Perspectives on Maternal Protectiveness in Domestic Violence: Implications for Practice
- 12 May 2015
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wiley in Child Abuse Review
- Vol. 24 (4) , 249-260
Abstract
Research into maternal protectiveness in domestic violence has focused either on women's experiences of mothering or children's experiences of growing up in domestic violence. This paper reports on a qualitative research study with both mothers and individuals who grew up in domestic violence that sought to explore perspectives on, and experiences of, maternal protectiveness in the two groups. The study used a feminist social constructionist theoretical perspective and a relational empowerment methodology, and involved interviews with nine mothers and 16 individuals who grew up in domestic violence. Thematic analysis revealed the different ways that mothers and children approached the question of so‐called ‘failure to protect’. Analysis revealed that themes of self‐blame by the mothers and mother‐blame by those who grew up in domestic violence were common, with three main thematic categories capturing the ways in which blame was constructed: (1) centring feminine traits; (2) self‐blame and guilt; and (3) the double bind of protection. The paper explores the gendered discourses about mothering and femininity that frame practices of self‐blame and mother‐blame, elaborating the double bind of protection that women face. The paper also explores the implications for practitioners who work with domestic violence in balancing the need to strengthen connections between mothers and children and, at the same time, safeguard children. Copyright © 2015 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.‘Thematic analysis revealed the different ways that mothers and children approached the question of so‐called ‘failure to protect’’Key Practitioner Messages: Mothers commonly blame themselves for so-called ‘failure to protect’ their children in domestic violence. Individuals who grew up in violence often blame their mothers for ‘failure to protect’. Mother‐blame draws on a range of femininity and victim‐blaming discourses that can entangle women and children further in violence. Practitioners can encourage communication between mothers and children to repair relationships after violence.Keywords
This publication has 23 references indexed in Scilit:
- Perspectives From Young People about Family Contact in Kinship Care: “Don't Push Us—Listen More”Australian Social Work, 2013
- Domestic Violence and the Place of Fear in Mother/Baby RelationshipsJournal of Interpersonal Violence, 2013
- SEEKING CONGRUENCEAustralian Feminist Studies, 2010
- Crossing the Great Divide: Response to Douglas and WalshViolence Against Women, 2010
- Readiness to Change: Mother-Child Relationship and Domestic Violence InterventionThe British Journal of Social Work, 2010
- Mothers, Domestic Violence, and Child ProtectionViolence Against Women, 2010
- More Responsibilities, Less Control: Understanding the Challenges and Difficulties Involved in Mothering in the Context of Domestic ViolenceThe British Journal of Social Work, 2009
- ‘Talking to My Mum’Journal of Social Work, 2006
- Using thematic analysis in psychologyQualitative Research in Psychology, 2006
- Violent Men as Good-enough Fathers?Violence Against Women, 2001