Use of Physically Based Models to Evaluate USDA Soil Moisture Classes
- 1 January 2011
- journal article
- Published by Wiley in Soil Science Society of America Journal
- Vol. 75 (1) , 181-191
Abstract
Soil Taxonomy differs from other international soil classification systems because it includes the estimation of the soil moisture regime (SMR) and is primarily based on the estimation of dry days in a soil moisture control section (SMCS). Alternatively, the International Committee on Soil Moisture and Temperature Regimes (ICOMMOTR) has proposed a new approach based on biweekly soil water potential values determined at a fixed depth. Currently, SMR estimation is performed through simple models (standard approaches), such as the Newhall and Billaux models, that are not physically based. The aims of this work were to test the appropriateness of both standard Soil Taxonomy and the ICOMMOTR approaches through the use of a hydrologic model based on the Richards equation (SWAP), and to evaluate possible SMR classification alternatives. The SWAP‐derived SMR classifications were compared with those derived by standard approaches, as well as the ICOMMOTR proposals, under eight pedoclimatic conditions (southern and northern Italy) where the SWAP model was calibrated and validated. The standard approaches clearly overestimated the dry conditions in the SMCS. Being mainly climate based, however, they were able to separate different pedoclimatic settings. In contrast, the physically based approach showed realistic results in terms of SMR estimation but did not differentiate pedoclimatic settings for either Soil Taxonomy or ICOMMOTR approaches. Three possible alternatives to SMR classification were investigated: (i) applying the ICOMMOTR classification approach supported by the use of hydrologic Richards‐based models; (ii) changing the rules of Soil Taxonomy for classifying SMR and SMCS to better fit “real” soil hydrologic behavior; and (iii) continuing to apply Newhall and Billaux models but clearly clarifying their climate‐driven criteria.Keywords
Funding Information
- Regional Agency for the Services to Agriculture and Forest
This publication has 20 references indexed in Scilit:
- SWAP, CropSyst and MACRO comparison in two contrasting soils cropped with maize in Northern ItalyAgricultural Water Management, 2010
- The soil water balance of rainfed and irrigated oats, Italian rye grass and rye using the CropSyst modelIrrigation Science, 2007
- Scaling Approach to Deduce Field Unsaturated Hydraulic Properties and Behavior from Laboratory Measurements on Small CoresVadose Zone Journal, 2006
- Hydropedology as a powerful tool for environmental policy researchGeoderma, 2006
- Hysteresis in soil water characteristics as a key to interpreting comparisons of laboratory and field measured hydraulic propertiesWater Resources Research, 2003
- Assessing Soil Moisture Regimes with Traditional and New MethodsSoil Science Society of America Journal, 2002
- Models of soil moisture dynamics in ecohydrology: A comparative studyWater Resources Research, 2002
- Integrated modelling of the soil–water–atmosphere–plant system using the model SWAP 2·0 an overview of theory and an applicationHydrological Processes, 2000
- Computer simulation of changes in soil mineral nitrogen and crop nitrogen during autumn, winter and springThe Journal of Agricultural Science, 1987
- Judging Air Quality Model PerformanceBulletin of the American Meteorological Society, 1981