Judicial Deference in the Relationship Between Constitutional Courts of the Member States and the European Court of Justice
- 22 June 2025
- journal article
- Published by Central European Academy in Law, Identity and Values
- Vol. 5 (1) , 217-237
Abstract
The concept of judicial deference is generally seen as a tool that judges use to avoid getting involved in areas they may consider to be beyond their expertise or jurisdiction. It is often discussed in the context of the connections between the constitutional courts and state authorities with regulatory or law enforcement powers. The concept of judicial deference can also be applied to the relationships of constitutional justice in the EU. In the complex context of the EU legal order, judicial deference becomes particularly important in the relationship between the constitutional courts and the European Court of Justice (ECJ). In our study, we will first analyse the concept of ‘judicial deference’ in the context of EU constitutional justice. Then we will examine the limits of power and intervention of the constitutional courts and ECJ, especially in sensitive areas such as the interaction of legal systems, fundamental rights, and constitutional identity. The goal of this scientific article is to analyse these unique features and challenges and to show that balanced judicial deference is crucial for the development of an ‘Ever-integrated Union.’.Keywords
This publication has 15 references indexed in Scilit:
- Restoring Dialogical Rule of Law in the European Union: Janus in the MirrorCambridge Yearbook of European Legal Studies, 2024
- Does the World Need an International Constitutional Court?SSRN Electronic Journal, 2022
- Courts vs. Courts? Or a way together? The evolution of constitutional review in the EU and worldwideRevista de Drept Constituțional, 2022
- THE PRELIMINARY RULING PROCEDURE AND THE IDENTITY REVIEWEu and Comparative Law Issues and Challenges Series (eclic), 2017
- The Dialogue of Constitutional Judges2016
- Towards a Theory of European Union Legal Systems*2012
- Are You Networked Yet? On Dialogues in European Judicial NetworksUtrecht Law Review, 2012
- The political and legal culture of European integration: An exploratory essayInternational Journal of Constitutional Law, 2011
- How Many Legal Systems? Some Puzzles Regarding the Identity Conditions of, and Relations between, Legal Systems in the European UnionSSRN Electronic Journal, 2008
- The legitimacy of judicial review: The limits of dialogue between courts and legislaturesInternational Journal of Constitutional Law, 2005