Artificial intelligence and machine learning (AI/ML) models are becoming increasingly prevalent in decision-making. Despite their increase application in many areas, little research has been conducted on human-machine interaction with ML. New models that are developed in computer science literature advocate they increase transparency, trust, and task performance for users, but little to no research has empirically tested these postulates. We tested aspects of the Lee and See (2004) theoretical model in relation to machine trust, exploring differences in the trust process between calibrated confidence models and uncalibrated confidence models across three studies in a dual-task environment. Results indicate calibrated confidence intervals increased task performance on the non-automated task (i.e., the task without ML), but not the automated task. Calibrated confidence models also resulted in higher trustworthiness perceptions and reliance intentions over time. Propensity to trust machines was related to initial trustworthiness perceptions but not actual behaviors in all three studies. Trustworthiness perceptions accounted for significant variance in relevant criteria, but reliance intentions did not. Results demonstrated calibrated confidence models increased the trust process, but we found mixed support for Lee and See’s theoretical model.