Leveraging the strengths of citizen science and structured surveys to achieve scalable inference on population size
Authors:
- Andrew N. StillmanASAndrew N. Stillman
- Paige E. HowellPHPaige E. Howell
- Guthrie S. ZimmermanGZGuthrie S. Zimmerman
- Emily R. BjerreEBEmily R. Bjerre
- Brian A. MillsapBMBrian A. Millsap
- Orin J. RobinsonOROrin J. Robinson
- Daniel FinkDFDaniel Fink
- Erica F. StuberESErica F. Stuber
- Viviana Ruiz‐GutierrezVRViviana Ruiz‐Gutierrez
- 10 October 2023
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Applied Ecology
- Vol. 60 (11) , 2389-2399
Abstract
Population size is a key metric for management and policy decisions, yet wildlife monitoring programmes are often limited by the spatial and temporal scope of surveys. In these cases, citizen science data may provide complementary information at higher resolution and greater extent. We present a case study demonstrating how data from the eBird citizen science programme can be combined with regional monitoring efforts by the US Fish and Wildlife Service to produce high‐resolution estimates of golden eagle abundance. We developed a model that uses aerial survey data from the western United States to calibrate high‐resolution annual estimates of relative abundance from eBird. Using this model, we compared regional population size estimates based on the calibrated eBird information with those based on aerial survey data alone. Population size estimates based on the calibrated eBird information had strong correspondence to estimates from aerial survey data in two out of four regions, and population trajectories based on the two approaches showed high correlations. We demonstrate how the combination of citizen science data and targeted surveys can be used to (a) increase the spatial resolution of population size estimates, (b) extend the spatial extent of inference and (c) predict population size beyond the temporal period of surveys. Findings based on this case study can be used to refine policy metrics used by the US Fish and Wildlife Service and inform permitting regulations (e.g. mortality/harm associated with wind energy development). Policy implications: Our results demonstrate the ability of citizen science data to complement targeted monitoring programmes and improve the efficacy of decision frameworks that require information on population size or trajectory. After validating citizen science data against survey‐based benchmarks, agencies can harness strengths of citizen science data to supplement information needs and increase the resolution and extent of population size predictions.Keywords
Funding Information
- U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service
This publication has 25 references indexed in Scilit:
- Using citizen science data in integrated population models to inform conservationBiological Conservation, 2018
- Stan: A Probabilistic Programming Language2017
- Golden Eagle fatalities and the continental‐scale consequences of local wind‐energy generationConservation Biology, 2016
- Modeling Late-Summer Distribution of Golden Eagles (Aquila chrysaetos) in the Western United StatesPLOS ONE, 2016
- Monitoring abundance of golden eagles in the western United StatesThe Journal of Wildlife Management, 2014
- Golden eagle population trends in the western United States: 1968–2010The Journal of Wildlife Management, 2013
- Analysis of the North American Breeding Bird Survey Using Hierarchical ModelsOrnithology, 2011
- Citizen Science as an Ecological Research Tool: Challenges and BenefitsAnnual Review of Ecology, Evolution, and Systematics, 2010
- A Population Estimate for Golden Eagles in the Western United StatesThe Journal of Wildlife Management, 2007
- Monitoring for conservationTrends in Ecology & Evolution, 2006