Systematic Comparison of Hedonic Ranking and Rating Methods Demonstrates Few Practical Differences
- 1 July 2013
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Food Science
- Vol. 78 (8) , S1257-S1263
Abstract
Hedonic ranking is one of the commonly used methods to evaluate consumer preferences. Some authors suggest that it is the best methodology for discriminating among products, while others recommend hedonic rating. These mixed findings suggest the statistical outcome(s) are dependent on the experimental conditions or a user's expectation of “ what is ” and “ what is not ” desirable for evaluating consumer preferences. Therefore, sensory and industry professionals may be uncertain or confused regarding the appropriate application of hedonic tests. This paper would like to put this controversy to rest, by evaluating 3 data sets (3 yogurts, 79 consumers; 6 yogurts, 109 consumers; 4 apple cultivars, 70 consumers) collected using the same consumers and by calculating nontied ranks from hedonic scores. Consumer responses were evaluated by comparing bivariate associations between the methods (nontied ranks, tied ranks, hedonic rating scores) using trellis displays, determining the number of consumers with discrepancies in their responses between the methods, and comparing mean values using conventional statistical analyses. Spearman's rank correlations (0.33–0.84) revealed significant differences between the methods for all products, whether or not means separation tests differentiated the products. The work illustrated the inherent biases associated with hedonic ranking and recommended alternate hedonic methodologies.Keywords
This publication has 22 references indexed in Scilit:
- Emotional response to fruit salads with different visual qualityFood Quality and Preference, 2013
- Measuring emotions associated with foods: Important elements of questionnaire and test designFood Quality and Preference, 2013
- Sensory profiles and preference analysis in ornamental horticulture: The case of the rosebushFood Quality and Preference, 2010
- Commentary on “Comparative performance of the nine-point hedonic, hybrid and self-adjusting scales in the generation of internal preference maps”Food Quality and Preference, 2010
- A comparison of the labeled magnitude (LAM) scale, an 11-point category scale and the traditional 9-point hedonic scaleFood Quality and Preference, 2010
- Derivation and Evaluation of a Labeled Hedonic ScaleChemical Senses, 2009
- Comparative performance of the nine-point hedonic, hybrid and self-adjusting scales in the generation of internal preference mapsFood Quality and Preference, 2009
- Performance of the hybrid hedonic scale as compared to the traditional hedonic, self-adjusting and ranking scalesFood Quality and Preference, 2005
- Discriminability and appropriateness of category scaling versus ranking methods to study sensory preferences in elderlyFood Quality and Preference, 2004
- Performance of three affective methods and diagnosis of the ANOVA modelFood Quality and Preference, 2000