Are South African anaesthesiologists fit for purpose? A comparison of opinions of graduates, teachers and examiners
Open Access
- 1 January 2020
- journal article
- review article
- Published by AOSIS in Southern African Journal of Anaesthesia and Analgesia
- Vol. 26 (6) , 272-278
Abstract
Background: Anaesthesiologists must be assessed as and deemed fit for purpose (FFP) to function independently as specialists prior to their embarking on independent practice. Opinions of various stakeholders are useful in determining whether graduating specialists are prepared for practice, some of which include teachers, examiners and the graduates themselves. Methods: This descriptive quantitative study comprised recent graduates and anaesthesiology teachers and examiners from all eight national university departments of anaesthesiology. Each participant scored the preparedness of graduates’ competences deemed appropriate by national experts via an electronic survey. Nine specialist role meta-competences (medical expert, communicator, collaborator, leader, health advocate, scholar, professional, context awareness, humaneness) with their accompanying 101 component enabling competences were assessed. Participants used a 4-point Likert scale to score preparedness for each meta- and enabling competence (1– completely unprepared; 2 – somewhat prepared; 3 – prepared; 4 – completely prepared). Scores of 1 and 2 were considered as unprepared and 3 and 4 as prepared. Scores of graduates, teachers and examiners were compared. After individual group comparisons, the scores of combined teachers and examiners (seniors) were compared with those of graduates. Results: Response rates for graduates, teachers and examiners were 85%, 68% and 96% respectively. Graduates felt prepared for 7/9 roles (medical expert, collaborator, communicator, professional, scholar, context awareness and humaneness) and unprepared for the roles of health advocate and leader. Teachers’ and examiners’ scores were similar, perceiving graduates as prepared for 4/9 roles (medical expert, collaborator, context awareness and humaneness) and unprepared for the majority of their roles (communicator, scholar, professional, leader and health advocate). Leader and health advocate roles were unanimously perceived as unprepared by all three groups. Statistically significant disparate scores were evident between seniors and graduates for the roles of communicator, scholar and professional, with graduates assessing themselves as more prepared compared to the opinions of seniors. Conclusion: According to South African national anaesthesiology teachers and examiners, local graduates may not be fit for purpose, despite the contrasting perceptions of graduates. Graduates’ self-assessment may be less objective than that of experienced opinions, necessitating the need for longitudinal assessments to establish the impact of experience on subsequent graduate perceptions The full article is available at https://doi.org/10.36303/SAJAA.2020.26.6.2397Keywords
This publication has 32 references indexed in Scilit:
- Satisfaction with ophthalmology residency training from the perspective of recent graduates: a cross-sectional studyBMC Medical Education, 2013
- Preparedness for practice: The perceptions of medical graduates and clinical teamsMedical Teacher, 2012
- Well prepared for work? Junior doctors' self-assessment after medical educationBMC Medical Education, 2011
- Are medical graduates ready to face the challenges of Foundation training?Postgraduate Medical Journal, 2011
- Validating objectives and training in Canadian paediatrics residency training programmesMedical Teacher, 2011
- Views of junior doctors about whether their medical school prepared them well for work: questionnaire surveysBMC Medical Education, 2010
- Are specialist registrars fully prepared for the role of consultant?The Clinical Teacher, 2009
- The new consultant survey 2005Emergency Medicine Journal, 2006
- Preparation for practice: how can medical schools better prepare PRHOs?Medical Teacher, 2006
- Meeting the non-clinical education and training needs of new consultantsPostgraduate Medical Journal, 2005