Do Anglers Know What They Catch? Identification Accuracy and Its Effect on Angler Survey-Derived Catch Estimates
Authors:
- 19 October 2012
- journal article
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in North American Journal of Fisheries Management
- Vol. 32 (6) , 1080-1089
Abstract
Angler surveys are reliant on the ability of anglers to accurately report various aspects of their fishing trips. Misidentification of sport fishes has been postulated as a source of error among angler surveys but has received little attention. We evaluated the overall ability of anglers to identify sport fishes common to Ohio and the potential impacts on catch estimates derived from angler surveys. During angler surveys conducted on lakes and reservoirs (2007, n = 34) and Ohio River tailwaters (2010, n = 3), anglers were presented with artist‐rendered images of 18 different sport fishes common to these waters. Anglers (lake and reservoir, n = 2,442; Ohio River, n = 458) were asked to identify sport fish by their common name. On average, anglers correctly identified sport fishes 42% of the time, but accuracy varied widely among species (lake and reservoir, range = 4.4–85.1%; Ohio River, range = 9.4–71.8%), with greater accuracy exhibited for the most common species (e.g., largemouth bass Micropterus salmoides). However, by grouping angler responses into species groups (e.g., black bass Micropterus spp., sunfish Lepomis spp.) angler identification of sport fishes was more reliable (lake and reservoir, mean = 83.4%; Ohio River, mean = 83.8%). Using these estimates of angler accuracy, we simulated the potential error in sport fish catch estimates using data from an angler survey conducted at one Ohio reservoir. These results suggested that misidentification error may result in a substantial error in catch estimates. A survey of North American fisheries management agencies regarding angler surveys and angler sport fish identification revealed that the majority of agencies group similar species for analysis and cited species misidentification by anglers as the primary reason for doing so. Received April 19, 2012; accepted August 17, 2012Keywords
Funding Information
- Sport Fish Restoration Act Project F-69-P
This publication has 17 references indexed in Scilit:
- Verifying Identification of Salmon and Trout by Boat Anglers in Lake OntarioNorth American Journal of Fisheries Management, 2011
- Recall Bias in a Sportfishing Mail SurveyNorth American Journal of Fisheries Management, 2010
- Fish Total Length Measurement Error from Recreational Anglers: Causes and Contribution to Noncompliance for the Mille Lacs Walleye FisheryNorth American Journal of Fisheries Management, 2004
- Accuracy of Angler-Reported Harvest in Roving Creel SurveysNorth American Journal of Fisheries Management, 2004
- Exaggeration of Walleye Catches by Alberta AnglersNorth American Journal of Fisheries Management, 2003
- Montana Anglers' Inability to Identify Bull Trout and other SalmonidsFisheries, 1999
- Status of Human Dimensions Surveys Sponsored by State and Provincial Fisheries Management Agencies in North AmericaFisheries, 1996
- Optimum Yield for Recreational Fisheries ManagementFisheries, 1996
- Use of Angler Diaries to Examine Biases Associated with 12-Month Recall on Mail QuestionnairesTransactions of the American Fisheries Society, 1995
- Effects of Recall Bias and Nonresponse Bias on Self-Report Estimates of Angling ParticipationNorth American Journal of Fisheries Management, 1993