Science to the rescue or contingent progress? Comparing 10 years of public, expert and policy discourses on new and emerging science and technology in the United Kingdom
Open Access
- 11 May 2017
- journal article
- research article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Public Understanding of Science
- Vol. 27 (6) , 655-673
Abstract
Over the past 10 years, numerous public debates on new and emerging science and technologies have taken place in the United Kingdom. In this article, we characterise the discourses emerging from these debates and compare them to the discourses in analogous expert scientific and policy reports. We find that while the public is broadly supportive of new scientific developments, they see the risks and social and ethical issues associated with them as unpredictable but inherent parts of the developments. In contrast, the scientific experts and policymakers see risks and social and ethical issues as manageable and quantifiable with more research and knowledge. We argue that these differences amount to two different sociotechnical imaginaries or views of science and how it shapes our world – an elite imaginary of ‘science to the rescue’ shared by scientists and policymakers and public counter-imaginary of ‘contingent progress’. We argue that these two imaginaries indicate that, but also help explain why, public dialogue has had limited impact on public policy.Keywords
Funding Information
- Economic and Social Research Council (Doctoral Training Award)
This publication has 35 references indexed in Scilit:
- Documents, practices and policyEvidence & Policy, 2011
- Producing the Post-Fordist Public: The Political Economy of Public Engagement with ScienceScience as Culture, 2010
- Analysing Parliamentary Debate with Computer AssistanceSwiss Political Science Review, 2007
- What drives public acceptance of nanotechnology?Nature Nanotechnology, 2006
- Deliberative Impacts: The Macro-Political Uptake of Mini-PublicsPolitics & Society, 2006
- Difficulties in evaluating public engagement initiatives: reflections on an evaluation of the UK GM Nation? public debate about transgenic cropsPublic Understanding of Science, 2005
- ‘The Scientists Think and the Public Feels’: Expert Perceptions of the Discourse of GM FoodDiscourse & Society, 2004
- Preferences Need no Inferences, Once Again: Germinal Elements in the Public Perceptions of Genetically Modified Foods in ColombiaPublic Understanding of Science, 2004
- Public Participation Methods: A Framework for EvaluationScience, Technology, & Human Values, 2000
- The public understanding of scienceNature, 1989