On the Modeling and Performance Assessment of Random Access With SIC
- 8 February 2018
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in IEEE Journal on Selected Areas in Communications
- Vol. 36 (2) , 292-303
Abstract
In this paper, we review the key figures of merit to assess the performance of advanced random access (RA) schemes exploiting physical layer coding, repetitions, and collision resolution techniques. We then investigate RA modeling aspects and their impact on the figures of merit for the exemplary advanced RA schemes: contention resolution diversity slotted ALOHA (CRDSA), irregular repetition slotted ALOHA (IRSA), coded slotted ALOHA (CSA) and enhanced spread-spectrum ALOHA (E-SSA). We show that the typical simplifications of the reception model when used to optimize RA schemes lead to inaccurate findings, both in terms of parameter optimization and figures of merit, such as the packet loss ratio (PLR) and throughput. We also derive a generic RA energy efficiency model able to compare the schemes in terms of the energy required to transmit a packet. The combination of achievable RA throughput at the target PLR and energy efficiency, for the same average user power investment per frame and occupied bandwidth, shows that E-SSA, which is an unslotted scheme, provides the best overall performance, while, in terms of the slotted schemes, CRDSA outperforms the more elaborated IRSA and CSA. This surprising results are due to the fact that the IRSA and CSA optimization has so far been performed using RA channel models that are not accurately reflecting the physical layer receiver behavior. We conclude by providing insights on how to include more accurate reception models in the IRSA and CSA design and optimization.Keywords
All Related Versions
Funding Information
- European Research Council, ERC Consolidator, in the Horizon 2020 Program (648382 WILLOW)
- National Research Fund, Luxembourg under AFR Grant for the Ph.D. Project on Reliable Communication Techniques for Future Generation Satellite Systems (10064089)
This publication has 17 references indexed in Scilit:
- Irregular repetition slotted ALOHA over the Rayleigh block fading channel with capture2017
- Enhancing the Physical Layer of Contention Resolution Diversity Slotted ALOHAIEEE Transactions on Communications, 2017
- Random access schemes for satellite networks, from VSAT to M2M: a surveyInternational Journal of Satellite Communications and Networking, 2016
- From S‐band mobile interactive multimedia to fixed satellite interactive multimedia: making satellite interactivity affordable at Ku‐band and Ka‐bandInternational Journal of Satellite Communications and Networking, 2015
- Coded Slotted ALOHA: A Graph-Based Method for Uncoordinated Multiple AccessIEEE Transactions on Information Theory, 2015
- Coded random access: applying codes on graphs to design random access protocolsIEEE Communications Magazine, 2015
- Error Floor Analysis of Coded Slotted ALOHA Over Packet Erasure ChannelsIEEE Communications Letters, 2014
- On the Optimum Packet Power Distribution for Spread Aloha Packet Detectors With Iterative Successive Interference CancelationIEEE Transactions on Wireless Communications, 2014
- Five disruptive technology directions for 5GIEEE Communications Magazine, 2014
- M2M Service Platforms: Survey, Issues, and Enabling TechnologiesIEEE Communications Surveys & Tutorials, 2013