Organic agriculture versus genetic engineering
Author:
- 1 August 2007
- journal article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in NJAS: Wageningen Journal of Life Sciences
- Vol. 54 (4) , 387-400
Abstract
The objections of organic agriculture against genetic engineering as presented in the 2002 Position Statement of the International Federation of Organic Agriculture Movements (IFOAM) are analysed. The objections can be grouped into three categories: risks to human health and the environment, socio-ethical objections, and incompatibility with the principles of sustainable agriculture. As to threats to human health and the environment it is argued that scientists contradict each other. Socio-ethical objections indicate that farmers should also be free to choose for or against genetic engineering and therefore the free-choice criterion needs to be specified. The argument of violating the independence of the farmer depends on the present economic situation (e.g. power of multinationals) and does not seem to be a consequence of genetic engineering as such. But as genetic engineering is mainly practised by multinational organizations the argument cannot be seen separate from the economic situation. Genetic pollution is a serious issue, but only because the organic movement is against genetic engineering on principle. Once the philosophical and ethical principles behind the organic concept of sustainability are specified (the third category), almost all the objections listed in IFOAM's Position Statement can be reformulated into good reasons for rejecting genetic engineering. The basic principles are: a holistic methodological approach to living nature, the self-organization (self-regulation) of living nature, and the integrity of living organisms.Keywords
This publication has 15 references indexed in Scilit:
- Organic values and the conventionalization of organic agricultureNJAS: Wageningen Journal of Life Sciences, 2007
- Organic agriculture requires process rather than product evaluation of novel breeding techniquesNJAS: Wageningen Journal of Life Sciences, 2007
- Principles of organic agriculture as formulated by the International Federation of Organic Agriculture MovementsNJAS: Wageningen Journal of Life Sciences, 2007
- Unintended consequences of plant transformation: A molecular insightJournal of Applied Genetics, 2006
- Concepts of Intrinsic Value and Integrity of Plants in Organic Plant Breeding and PropagationCrop Science, 2003
- Urban myths of organic farmingNature, 2001
- A synthetic cryIC gene, encoding a Bacillus thuringiensis δ-endotoxin, confers Spodoptera resistance in alfalfa and tobaccoProceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 1996
- Aiming for the discursive high ground: Monsanto and the biotechnology controversySociological Forum, 1991
- Modification of the coding sequence enhances plant expression of insect control protein genes.Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 1991
- Efficient transformation of Arabidopsis thaliana using direct gene transfer to protoplastsMolecular Genetics and Genomics, 1989