In Japan, endoscopic treatment is considered the treatment of choice for early gastroesophageal neoplasia. In the 1970 s, the high incidence of gastric cancer in Japan led to the initiation of screening programs, initially with double contrast studies and later with endoscopic inspection. As a result, the number of gastric and esophageal cancers detected at an early stage increased dramatically, and the endoscopic treatment of these early lesions evolved as a logical consequence. Initially early gastric and esophageal cancers were treated with endoscopic mucosal resection (EMR) techniques, of which the cap-based techniques are the most widely accepted [ 1 ]. These techniques suffer from the limitation that only lesions of a relatively small size can be resected in one piece (i. e., en bloc resection). Lesions larger than 15 – 20 mm generally require resection in multiple pieces (i. e., piecemeal resection) [ 1 ] [ 2 ] [ 3 ] [ 4 ]. After piecemeal resection, however, it is difficult to assess the radicality at the resection margins. The radicality at the vertical resection margin can usually be adequately assessed, but since it is generally impossible to reconstruct the lesion from the resected specimens, radicality at the lateral resection margins can be uncertain. To avoid this problem, a new technique was developed that allows en bloc resection of larger lesions. This technique, known as endoscopic submucosal dissection (ESD), starts with the endoscopic circumcision of a lesion, followed by dissection starting at the lateral edges and working through the submucosal layer until the lesion is removed in one piece. Large cohort studies, again from Japan, suggest that ESD is associated with a significantly higher rate of radical en bloc resections, which reduces the rate of local recurrences during follow-up [ 1 ] [ 2 ] [ 3 ] [ 4 ]. These studies, all from expert centers, have shown remarkably few complications, although a perforation rate of 5 % – 7 % is generally reported [ 1 ] [ 2 ] [ 3 ] [ 4 ]. These perforations are usually small in size and are most often detected and managed during the endoscopic intervention without compromising its success. These procedures are, however, considered to be technically demanding, with average procedure times of several hours even in expert hands. What is unique about ESD in Japan? The Japanese setting is ideal for learning and practicing ESD. The most frequently encountered early neoplastic lesions in Japan are in the distal stomach. This is the area where the muscularis propria is relatively thick and where endoscopic maneuvers are easier to perform than in the proximal stomach or esophagus [ 1 ]. There are also fewer blood vessels, and they are smaller, than at more proximal locations in the stomach. Furthermore, endoscopic treatment of early neoplasia is widely practiced in Japan, and most trained endoscopists are familiar with the different EMR techniques. Against this background, moving into the more technically demanding area of ESD is relatively easy. The ESD skills are superimposed upon the EMR skills and a stepwise approach can be followed, starting with ESD of the most frequently encountered lesions in the distal stomach, then moving to lesions in the proximal stomach, with esophageal and colonic lesions as the final step [ 1 ] [ 5 ]. The esophagus and colon are considered more difficult for ESD because maneuverability is limited and the muscle layer is much thinner [ 6 ]. The general rule in Japan is that a minimum of 50 ESDs should be performed in the distal stomach before moving to the more complicated lesions and difficult locations [ 1 ] [ 5 ]. In the West, the setting for learning and practicing ESD is completely different. First, EMR is not widely practiced: in few Western countries is endoscopic treatment of early gastrointestinal neoplasia considered the treatment of choice, and not many Western endoscopists have enough experience with EMR onto which to superimpose their ESD experience [ 7 ] [ 8 ]. Second, early gastric cancer is relatively rare in the West; most of our early cancers are discovered in patients with Barrett’s esophagus. This makes it difficult to gain enough ESD experience with gastric cases before moving into the more dangerous locations in the esophagus or colon. Most tertiary referral centers will see fewer than 10 suitable patients per year, making it very hard to accumulate the 50 cases required to become proficient according to Japanese standards. The danger therefore exists that Western endoscopists will be tempted to practice ESD in the lesions they most frequently encounter: early Barrett’s cancers and colonic polyps. It is questionable whether ESD is justified for these indications. Early Barrett’s cancer generally develops against a background of a ”field defect”. Delineating the lesion is therefore difficult: after en bloc EMR of small lesions, only 20 % are found upon histological evaluation to have negative resection margins [ 9 ]. This is likely to be the case after ESD as well. In addition, the Barrett’s mucosa that is left behind after endoscopic resection of focal lesions is associated with a recurrence rate of up to 30 % within 3 years [ 10 ] [ 11 ]. To reduce this risk, additional treatment is therefore required for the remaining Barrett’s segment, and effective tools for this are now available. In expert hands, stepwise endoscopic resection of the whole Barrett’s esophagus using piecemeal EMR has been shown to be effective in reducing the number of recurrences during follow-up [ 12 ] [ 13 ] [ 14 ]. In addition, combining endoscopic resection with radiofrequency ablation (RFA) may be safer than widespread endoscopic resection, since RFA maintains the functional integrity of the esophagus and is easier to perform [ 15 ] [ 16 ] [ 17 ] [ 18 ]. The availability of effective tools for treating the residual Barrett’s mucosa after...