Comparative statistical performance of prehospital scoring systems with and without incorporating age for predicting multiple trauma outcomes: an observational study
Authors:
- 25 November 2025
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Nature in European Journal of Trauma and Emergency Surgery
- Vol. 51 (1) , 346
Abstract
Purpose Prehospital trauma scoring systems have traditionally used mortality as the primary outcome, but trauma is complex condition with diverse presentations and outcomes, each of which are moderated by age. We assess the predictive performance of six prehospital trauma scoring systems across multiple outcomes, and explore the inclusion of simple age categorisations on predictive validity. Methods This retrospective observational study used nationwide, linked prehospital data from the National Ambulance Service (NAS) and in-hospital data from the Irish Major Trauma Audit (MTA) where the inclusion criteria are based on Injury Severity Score (ISS), length of stay and injury details. 101,114 adult trauma patients were included. Six trauma scoring systems were applied to the data and predictive performance was compared for three outcomes: major trauma (ISS > 15), MTA inclusion, and in-hospital mortality. For tools not originally including age, prior validated age categories were added and predictive performance re-assessed. Results All trauma scores performed suboptimally in predicting ISS > 15 (C-statistics 0.61–0.71). For MTA inclusion, no model performed acceptably (≤ 0.64). Mortality prediction was acceptable/good (0.71–0.87). Including simple age categorisations into existing tools reduced each tool’s predictive accuracy for ISS > 15, yielded modest improvements for MTA inclusion, and improved mortality prediction. Conclusions Trauma scoring systems were most effective at predicting mortality, especially when age was included. However, they were less effective for identifying major trauma (ISS > 15) or MTA inclusion, even with age different age inclusions. The New Trauma Score, which includes oxygen saturation, showed the best overall performance for major trauma.Keywords
All Related Versions
Funding Information
- Health Research Board (SDAP-2021-006)
- Health Research Board (SDAP-2021-006)
- Health Research Board (SDAP-2021-006)
- Health Research Board (SDAP-2021-006)
- Health Research Board (SDAP-2021-006)
- Health Research Board (SDAP-2021-006)
- Health Research Board (SDAP-2021-006)
- Health Research Board (SDAP-2021-006)
- Health Research Board (SDAP-2021-006)
- Health Research Board (SDAP-2021-006)
- Health Research Board (SDAP-2021-006)
- Health Research Board (SDAP-2021-006)
- Health Research Board (SDAP-2021-006)
- Health Research Board (SDAP-2021-006)
- Health Research Board (SDAP-2021-006)
- Health Research Board (SDAP-2021-006)
- Health Research Board (SDAP-2021-006)
- Health Research Board (SDAP-2021-006)
This publication has 30 references indexed in Scilit:
- Substantial heterogeneity in trauma triage tool characteristic operationalization for identification of major trauma: a hybrid systematic reviewEuropean Journal of Trauma and Emergency Surgery, 2025
- Comparison of GAP, R-GAP, and new trauma score (NTS) systems in predicting mortality of traffic accidents that injure hospitals at Mashhad University of medical sciencesHeliyon, 2024
- A retrospective study on evaluating GAP, MGAP, RTS and ISS trauma scoring system for the prediction of mortality among multiple trauma patientsAnnals of Medicine & Surgery, 2022
- The contribution of frailty, cognition, activity of daily life and comorbidities on outcome in acutely admitted patients over 80 years in European ICUs: the VIP2 studyIntensive Care Medicine, 2019
- Trauma models to identify major trauma and mortality in the prehospital settingBritish Journal of Surgery, 2019
- Age-Related Characteristics and Outcomes for Patients With Severe Trauma: Analysis of Japan’s Nationwide Trauma RegistryAnnals of Emergency Medicine, 2019
- The differential mortality of Glasgow Coma Score in patients with and without head injuryInjury, 2016
- Factors affecting mortality in older trauma patients—A systematic review and meta-analysisInjury, 2016
- Implementing Major Trauma Audit in IrelandInjury, 2016
- Defining major trauma using the 2008 Abbreviated Injury ScaleInjury, 2016