An experimental study of criteria for hypothesis plausibility
Authors:
- 27 April 1991
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Journal of Experimental & Theoretical Artificial Intelligence
- Vol. 3 (2) , 129-144
Abstract
Abductive diagnostic problem-solving systems use causal relations to infer plausible diagnostic hypotheses. An important but controversial issue for such models is what characteristics should define the most plausible hypotheses. While there are theoretical predictions relevant to this issue, there are almost no empirical data on which to base rational decisions. Accordingly, this study examines four different criteria of hypothesis plausibility in diagnosing the site of brain damage in 100 medical patients. The criteria examined are (1) naive minimal cardinality, (2) irredundancy, (3) most probable (Bayesian), and (4) minimal cardinality when adjacency relations are taken into account. Model performance when these different hypothesis plausibility criteria are used confirms the previously predicted inadequacy of minimal cardinality. It also indicates that irredundancy (‘minimality’), the criterion most widely used in current AI models, is not useful in this setting because of the large number of alternative, implausible hypotheses it produces. The most interesting result is that a modified minimal cardinality criterion produces the best hypotheses when measured as the ratio of agreements with human experts per hypothesis generated. In addition, comparing the results of this study to two previous rule-based systems for a similar application indicates that abductive diagnostic systems can be very powerful as application programs. These results, useful in themselves, underscore the need for more systematic empirical studies of abductive problem-solving models.Keywords
This publication has 13 references indexed in Scilit:
- Abductive Inference Models for Diagnostic Problem-Solving1990
- The Stroke Data Bank: design, methods, and baseline characteristics.Stroke, 1988
- Towards a 'neural' architecture for abductive reasoning1988
- Distributed revision of composite beliefsArtificial Intelligence, 1987
- A Mechanism for Forming Composite Explanatory HypothesesIEEE Transactions on Systems, Man, and Cybernetics, 1987
- A Probabilistic Causal Model for Diagnostic Problem Solving Part I: Integrating Symbolic Causal Inference with Numeric Probabilistic InferenceIEEE Transactions on Systems, Man, and Cybernetics, 1987
- Computer-Aided Assessment of Transient Ischemic AttacksArchives of Neurology, 1984
- Symbolic coordinate anatomy for neurology (SCAN)Journal of Medical Systems, 1984
- Diagnostic expert systems based on a set covering modelInternational Journal of Man-Machine Studies, 1983
- Internist-I, an Experimental Computer-Based Diagnostic Consultant for General Internal MedicineNew England Journal of Medicine, 1982