Explaining Away Dyslexia

Author:
  • JPJ. Presland
    J. Presland

Abstract
That some children do themselves less than justice at reading, writing or spelling is widely known and accepted. The ways in which such discrepancies are conceptualised, however, is a matter of dispute. This article is a response to the challenge of Miles (1989) to explain away the evidence in favour of the concept of dyslexia as an anomalous ‘condition’ which certain people with reading difficulties share and which can be ameliorated by unique teaching methods — as opposed to different people having differing individual patterns of difficulties and therefore requiring teaching programmes which select from a wider range of techniques. In considering this issue, a range of educational/psychological research is examined, including the work of Miles and his associates. It is concluded that a highly specific condition called ‘dyslexia’ cannot be defined in any agreed way; that children with such a condition cannot be clearly identified; and that children who are identified as dyslexic by one definition or another cannot be said to need one particular approach to teaching which is different from what other children with specific reading difficulties need.

This publication has 25 references indexed in Scilit: