Aprotic alkali metal–O 2 batteries store two electrons per O 2 moiety during the reversible formation of solid insulating alkali metal peroxides. The second electron transfer on both discharge and charge, however, has eluded direct control as it typically occurs via disproportionation (DISP) of the superoxide intermediate. Critically, superoxide DISP is recognized to be a major cause of cell degradation, through the formation of highly reactive singlet oxygen. Here, we show that two-electron mediators suppress DISP and facilitate control over the kinetics and products of the second electron transfer. With a single encounter between the O 2 moiety and mediator, a single mediator compound transfers two electrons consecutively to first form a superoxo intermediate, and then to further reduce it to peroxide on discharge, or to oxidise it to O 2 on charge. Controlling the second electron transfer in this manner suppresses the electrolyte-dependent DISP. More generally, two-electron mediation transforms the previously EC mechanisms, where control over the chemical (C) step is often difficult, into mediated EE mechanisms with better control over all electron transfers.