From amazing work to I beg to differ - analysis of bioRxiv preprints that received one public comment till September 2019
Preprint
Abstract
While early commenting on studies is seen as one of the advantages of preprints, the nature of such comments, and the people who post them, have not been systematically explored. We analysed comments posted between 21 May 2015 and 9 September 2019 for 1,983 bioRxiv preprints that received only one comment. Sixty-nine percent of comments were posted by non-authors (n=1,366), and 31% by preprint authors (n=617). Twelve percent of non-author comments (n=168) were full review reports traditionally found during journal review, while the rest most commonly contained praises (n=577, 42%), suggestions (n=399, 29%), or criticisms (n=226, 17%). Authors’ comments most commonly contained publication status updates (n=354, 57%), additional study information (n=158, 26%), or solicited feedback for the preprints (n=65, 11%). Our study points to the value of preprint commenting, but further studies are needed to determine the role that comments play in shaping preprint versions and eventual journal publications.Keywords
All Related Versions
- Published version: Biochemia Medica, 31 (2), 177.
This publication has 19 references indexed in Scilit:
- Preprinting the COVID-19 pandemicbioRxiv, 2020
- A do-it-yourself overlay journalOSF Preprints, 2019
- Comparing published scientific journal articles to their pre-print versionsInternational Journal on Digital Libraries, 2018
- Altmetric Scores, Citations, and Publication of Studies Posted as PreprintsJAMA, 2018
- The prehistory of biology preprints: A forgotten experiment from the 1960sPLOS Biology, 2017
- Preprints na comunicação científica da Física de Altas Energias: análise das submissões no repositório arXiv (2010-2015)Perspectivas em Ciência da Informação, 2017
- Bacterial invasion of the pancreas revealed after analyses of the pancreatic cyst fluidsbioRxiv, 2016
- The role of arXiv, RePEc, SSRN and PMC in formal scholarly communicationAslib Journal of Information Management, 2015
- arXiv E‐prints and the journal of record: An analysis of roles and relationshipsJournal of the Association for Information Science and Technology, 2014
- A Measure of Agreement for Interval or Nominal Multivariate ObservationsEducational and Psychological Measurement, 2001