“It’s not just hacking for the sake of it”: a qualitative study of health innovators’ views on patient-driven open innovations, quality and safety
- 16 September 2020
- journal article
- research article
- Published by BMJ in BMJ Quality & Safety
- Vol. 30 (9) , 731-738
Abstract
Background Open do-it-yourself (DIY) health innovations raise new dilemmas for patient-oriented and service-oriented scholars and healthcare providers. Our study aimed to generate practical insights into quality and safety issues to patient care raised by two volunteer-run, open DIY solutions: Nightscout Project (patient-driven, open-source software for type 1 diabetes management) and e-NABLE (volunteers who design and three-dimensionally print upper-limb assistive devices). To this end, we examined the views of health innovators who are knowledgeable about medical devices standards and regulations. Methods We applied a multimedia-based, data-elicitation technique to conduct indepth interviews with a diversified sample of 31 health innovators practising in two Canadian provinces (Quebec and Ontario). An exploratory thematic analysis approach was used to identify respondents’ reasoning processes and compare their overall judgements of Nightscout and e-NABLE. Results Respondents pondered the following quality and safety issues: importance of the need addressed; accessibility; volunteers’ ability to develop and maintain a safe solution of good quality; risks involved for users; consequences of not using the solution; and liability. Overall, innovators see Nightscout as a high-risk DIY solution that requires expert involvement and e-NABLE as a low-risk one that fills a hard-to-meet gap. Conclusion Health innovators generally support patient-driven initiatives but also call for the involvement of professionals who possess complementary skills and knowledge. Our findings provide a list of issues healthcare providers may discuss with patients during clinical consultations to document potential risks and benefits of open DIY solutions. To inform new policy approaches, we propose the development of publicly funded umbrella organisations to act as intermediaries between open DIY solutions and regulatory bodies to help them meet quality and safety standards.Keywords
Funding Information
- Santé
- Canadian Institutes of Health Research (#FDN-143294)
This publication has 37 references indexed in Scilit:
- ‘Do-It-Yourself’ Healthcare? Quality of Health and Healthcare Through Wearable SensorsScience and Engineering Ethics, 2016
- Open-source hardware for medical devicesBMJ Innovations, 2016
- Are Patients and Relatives the Better Innovators? The Case of Medical Smartphone ApplicationsSSRN Electronic Journal, 2016
- Innovations by and for Patients, and Their Place in the Future Health Care System2016
- Cancer and fertility preservation: international recommendations from an expert meetingBMC Medicine, 2016
- Unmet needs: relevance to medical technology innovation?Journal of Medical Engineering & Technology, 2015
- A case study in open source innovation: developing the Tidepool Platform for interoperability in type 1 diabetes managementJournal of the American Medical Informatics Association, 2015
- Can Standards and Regulations Keep Up With Health Technology?JMIR mHealth and uHealth, 2015
- Standards for Reporting Qualitative ResearchAcademic Medicine, 2014
- Seeing health and illness worlds – using visual methodologies in a sociology of health and illness: a methodological reviewSociology of Health & Illness, 2002