‘Formative good, summative bad?’ – A review of the dichotomy in assessment literature
- 6 January 2015
- journal article
- review article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Journal of Further and Higher Education
- Vol. 40 (4) , 509-525
Abstract
The debate between summative and formative assessment is creating a situation that increasingly calls to mind the famous slogan in George Orwell’s (1945) Animal Farm – ‘Four legs good, two legs bad’. Formative assessment is increasingly being portrayed in the literature as ‘good’ assessment, which tutors should strive towards, whereas summative assessment is ‘bad’ assessment on which tutors should minimise their focus, instead moving towards formative assessment (Taras 2005). By revisiting the origins of formative assessment, this article aims to bring back to light that summative and formative assessment are connected at their inception. It highlights how research in the literature has unintentionally created a harmful dichotomy between summative and formative assessment, and it identifies some attempts in the literature to re-connect formative and summative assessment. This paper challenges the dichotomy in the literature and invites those in higher education to consider the fundamental idea that formative and summative assessment need to work in harmony and should not be seen as contrary to each other.Keywords
This publication has 30 references indexed in Scilit:
- Perceptions and realities in the functions and processes of assessmentActive Learning in Higher Education, 2012
- Recent Research on Human Learning Challenges Conventional Instructional StrategiesEducational Researcher, 2010
- Group-Based Formative Summative Assessment Relates to Improved Student Performance and SatisfactionTeaching of Psychology, 2010
- The Role of Assessment in a Learning CultureEducational Researcher, 2000
- Assessment and Classroom Learning: a role for summative assessment?Assessment in Education: Principles, Policy & Practice, 1998
- Assessment and Classroom LearningAssessment in Education: Principles, Policy & Practice, 1998
- Two Models of Educational AssessmentAssessment & Evaluation in Higher Education, 1996
- Strategies to enhance student motivation: A conceptual analysisStudies in Higher Education, 1996
- Assessment for Measurement or Standards: The Peril and Promise of Large-Scale Assessment ReformAmerican Educational Research Journal, 1994
- Instructional Alignment: Searching for a Magic BulletEducational Researcher, 1987