Evaluating multiple candidates simultaneously reduces racial disparities in promotion and tenure
Open Access
- 23 February 2026
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Nature in Nature Communications
- Vol. 17 (1)
Abstract
Black and Hispanic faculty – underrepresented minorities (URMs) within academia – face career barriers that come to a crux in promotion and tenure decisions. Leveraging a natural experiment in choice architecture within a dataset of 1804 promotion and tenure decisions across six universities, we find that joint (906 faculty) vs. separate (898 faculty) evaluation reduces racial disparities in faculty outcomes. Specifically, in joint evaluation, an analysis of the simple slopes finds that Black and Hispanic faculty receive, on average, 9% fewer negative votes at the department level than in separate evaluations when controlling for research productivity, school, gender, rank, discipline, department size, and grant acquisition. Using moderated mediation analyses, we calculate that this translates into a 16.2% increase in the likelihood of a Black/Hispanic faculty member receiving a promotion. In a survey of 289 professors who have served on promotion and tenure committees (i.e., the key P&T decision-makers), we find that only 17% of faculty expect joint evaluation to improve underrepresented minority faculty outcomes and, conversely, 43% expect separate evaluation to improve underrepresented minority faculty outcomes. This natural experiment suggests that altering evaluation mode or simulating joint evaluation mode could help address academia’s underrepresentation problem, but not in the way decision-makers expect.Keywords
Funding Information
- National Science Foundation (2100034)
This publication has 65 references indexed in Scilit:
- External review letters in academic promotion and tenure decisions are reflective of reviewer characteristicsResearch Policy, 2023
- Leveraging Nudges to Improve the Academic Workplace: Challenges and Possibilities2022
- How Gender and Race Stereotypes Impact the Advancement of Scholars in STEM: Professors’ Biased Evaluations of Physics and Biology Post-Doctoral CandidatesSex Roles, 2019
- Gender and ethnic stereotypes in student teachers’ judgments: a new look from a shifting standards perspectiveSocial Psychology of Education, 2017
- Associations between a patient-reported outcome (PRO) measure of sarcopenia and falls, functional status, and physical performance in older patients with cancerJournal of Geriatric Oncology, 2015
- On making causal claims: A review and recommendationsThe Leadership Quarterly, 2010
- Affective, Continuance, and Normative Commitment to the Organization: A Meta-analysis of Antecedents, Correlates, and ConsequencesJournal of Vocational Behavior, 2002
- The Evaluability Hypothesis: An Explanation for Preference Reversals between Joint and Separate Evaluations of AlternativesOrganizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes, 1996
- Stereotypes and social judgment: Extremity, assimilation, and contrast.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 1988
- The causal assumptions of quasi-experimental practiceSynthese, 1986