Chapter 2 is concerned with two interconnected matters. One is why, given her contemporary importance, Olive Schreiner is not better known in sociology now, and whether this can be explained as a general forgetting or an active process of exclusion that affected particular groups and individuals more than others. The other concerns Schreiner’s high-profile public intellectual role, and in examining this in detail an overview of the production of Schreiner’s key publications is provided. Connecting them is a discussion of developments and changes to sociology itself from the 1880s on. Schreiner’s exclusion was complicated, involved private troubles as well as public issues about disciplines and the universities system, and also her critique of what she described as a frozen rationality characterising scientific approaches. The chapter concludes by reconceiving the idea of a public intellectual and how it relates to the Schreiner theoria.