The deep(er) roots of Eukaryotes and Akaryotes
Authors:
Open Access
- 13 February 2020
- journal article
- research article
- Published by F1000 Research Ltd in F1000Research
- Vol. 9, 112
Abstract
Background: Locating the root node of the “tree of life” (ToL) is one of the hardest problems in phylogenetics. The root-node or the universal common ancestor (UCA) divides descendants into organismal domains. Two notable variants of the two-domains ToL (2D-ToL) have gained support recently. One 2D-ToL posits that eukaryotes (organisms with nuclei) and akaryotes (organisms without nuclei) are sister clades that diverged from the UCA and that Asgard archaea are sister to other archaea, whereas the other proposes that eukaryotes emerged within archaea and places Asgard archaea sister to eukaryotes. Williams et al. (Nature Ecol. Evol. 4: 138–147; 2020) re-evaluated the data and methods that support the competing two-domains proposals and concluded that eukaryotes are the closest relatives of Asgard archaea. Critique: We argue that important aspects of estimating evolutionary relatedness and assessing phylogenetic signal in empirical data were overlooked. We focus on phylogenetic character reconstructions necessary to describe the UCA or its closest descendants in the absence of reliable fossils. It is well known that different character types present different perspectives on evolutionary history that relate to different phylogenetic depths. Which 2D-ToL is better supported depends on which kind of molecular features – protein-domains or their component amino acids – are better for resolving common ancestors at the roots of clades. In practice, this involves reconstructing character compositions of the ancestral nodes all the way back to the UCA. We believe the criticisms of 2D-ToL focus on superficial aspects of the data and reflects common misunderstandings of phylogenetic reconstructions using protein domains (folds). Clarifications: Models of protein domain evolution support more reliable phylogenetic reconstructions. In contrast, even the best available amino acid substitution models fail to resolve the archaeal radiation, despite employing thousands of genes. Therefore, the primary domains Eukaryotes and Akaryotes are better supported in a 2D-ToL.Keywords
All Related Versions
This publication has 36 references indexed in Scilit:
- Phylogenomics provides robust support for a two-domains tree of lifeNature Ecology & Evolution, 2019
- What is an archaeon and are the Archaea really unique?PeerJ, 2018
- Mitochondria are not captive bacteriaJournal of Theoretical Biology, 2017
- Akaryotes and Eukaryotes are independent descendants of a universal common ancestorBiochimie, 2017
- Asgard archaea illuminate the origin of eukaryotic cellular complexityNature, 2017
- The phylogenomics of protein structures: The backstoryBiochimie, 2015
- Molecular homology and multiple-sequence alignment: an analysis of concepts and practiceAustralian Systematic Botany, 2015
- Complex archaea that bridge the gap between prokaryotes and eukaryotesNature, 2015
- Rooted phylogeny of the three superkingdomsBiochimie, 2013
- MOLECULAR VERSUS MORPHOLOGICAL APPROACHES TO SYSTEMATICSAnnual Review of Ecology and Systematics, 1987