Recent work in the philosophy of technology draws attention to the connection between technology and the good life. Discourse around emerging technologies also makes this connection, albeit implicitly, when it focuses on the promises and perils of going forward with a nascent technology. Emerging technologies are touted for their potential to bring about increased safety, health, convenience, or enlightenment and disparaged for their perils—diminished freedom, erosion of privacy, new vulnerabilities to nature. Use of the promises-and-perils framework is commonplace and rarely challenged. A comparison between the promises-and-perils framework and cost-benefit analysis reveals some of the advantages and disadvantages of promises-and-perils thinking. Uncertainty is an overarching problem and that makes plausibility important. How can the plausibility of promises and perils be assessed? A sociotechnical systems understanding of technology reveals at least three sources of uncertainty, and these provide some basis for evaluating the plausibility of promises and perils.